59 pages 1 hour read

Where Butterflies Wander

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2024

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 51-64Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 51 Summary: “Davina”

Davina wakes up feeling hazy in the hospital. She asks the nurse to bring the sheriff so that she can talk to him.

Chapter 52 Summary: “Hannah”

Hannah tries to get rid of a headache but is interrupted by Penelope, who wants to go to Davina’s garden to get blueberries. Hannah reluctantly joins her, but when they get to where the cabin used to be, they see their mother sitting amongst the rubble, staring into the woods. They are worried and slowly back away, not wanting her to know they are there.

Chapter 53 Summary: “Brendon”

As Brendon works to scrape old paint off the side of the house, he thinks back to the night before, when he and Davina were in the boat. Davina made it clear that she knew Brendon had burned down the cabin and hinted that he has the ability to make up for the mistakes he has made. She mentioned how he had already saved his dog and helped them get to town. Brendon took this advice seriously and now aims to do more good deeds. When Rock comes by to find out how Davina is doing, Marie says that she’s still in recovery. She seems unable to look at Brendon, signaling to him that she knows he burned down the cabin.

Chapter 54 Summary: “Penelope”

Davina only wants Brendon to visit, nobody else. In an attempt to be kinder and more easygoing, Brendon ruffles Penelope’s hair. This surprises her at first, but soon they’re laughing together.

Chapter 55 Summary: “Marie”

Lying in bed with Leo, Marie thinks about the moment she went to visit Davina in the hospital. Davina seemed totally uninterested in talking to Marie and only wanted to know how Banjo and Brendon were doing. Sensing that Davina knew what Brendon did, Marie proposed that they each keep each other’s secrets. Davina just responded that she wanted to see Brendon and wanted him to bring her belongings from the shed. Outside, Marie sat in her car and thought about how little she knows her children or her husband. She wondered if everyone puts on a mask as they go about their lives. Thinking about Brendon, Marie realized how little materialistic possessions matter and felt guilty for putting all her focus on the new house instead of her children. Although Marie cannot save Bee, she can still save Brendon, and she knows exactly how to do that now.

Chapter 56 Summary: “Leo”

Leo wakes up refreshed after reconnecting with Marie the night before. Marie decides to try and find Davina’s daughter using her keen research skills. Penelope helps by supplying a picture of Davina with her daughter and husband from the photo album she found. Brendon gets ready to leave to visit Davina, and Penelope gives him some muffins to take to her.

Chapter 57 Summary: “Hannah”

Rock sends Hannah an email explaining that he can’t see her anymore because he is tired of seeing Davina in pain and being associated with the family who caused it. Hannah feels heartbroken, which is a new experience for her. She writes a letter from Juliet to someone whose partner isn’t attracted to them due to their size. Hannah assures the writer that anyone who truly loves her will love her exactly as she is.

Chapter 58 Summary: “Davina”

Davina lets Brendon sit in awkwardness for a while so that he can reflect on everything that has taken place. She thinks about how she went to Afghanistan in order to pay for her mother’s hospice bills, which her husband refused to do. Davina tells Brendon that she wants him to drive her boat to her new home. She also wants Brendon to go to the sheriff’s office and make a statement about the trap and his dog. Davina adds that the man who has been setting traps was blamed for the fire and that she has no plans to tell anyone the truth.

Chapter 59 Summary: “Brendon”

Things are awkward between Brendon and his mother now, but she lets him drive Davina’s boat anyway, trusting him enough to have this responsibility. Brendon enjoys the calm and clear day and makes it to dock safely. He finds Rock with a man named Lloyd, fixing up Davina’s new house before she moves in. Brendon asks if he can help, but Rock hints that Lloyd doesn’t like him because of everything that happened. Rock drives Brendon home, and Brendon suggests that Rock should try talking to Hannah.

Chapter 60 Summary: “Penelope”

The family plans to move back to their old house, no longer wanting to outrun Bee’s memory. Penelope looks through the photo albums for pictures to frame for Davina’s new home. Hannah is making a cake for Davina. Penelope finds lots of great pictures: One of Davina as a child with her fishing pole is particularly striking. It reminds Penelope of how Bee led her to Davina in the form of a butterfly.

Chapter 61 Summary: “Davina”

Davina arrives at her new home to a welcome party. She feels overwhelmed with love and a sense of communal support. After greeting everyone, Davina has a chance to talk to Rock and tells him that he’s a fool for letting Hannah go. Rock seems motivated by this and takes off in his truck. Davina’s new home has been renovated but still has the same feeling as when she was a child. She sees the photos brought by Penelope, including the one of herself, one of Rosalinda, and one of Davina with the colonel. Davina hears the mailbox open and sees Marie driving away. She takes an envelope out of the mailbox and discovers that Marie found Davina’s daughter and her contact details. Davina wrestles with the strong desire to contact her daughter and the fear that she won’t be wanted in her life.

Chapter 62 Summary: “Hannah”

Hannah wakes up to the sound of pebbles hitting her window. Rock is standing outside. Hannah is still angry with him but also eager to make up. She goes downstairs, and her mother suggests that she take Rock to the river. Hannah goes outside, and she and Rock kiss. She tells him that she’s leaving tomorrow, and they go to the river to spend one last night together.

Chapter 63 Summary: “Marie”

The family is back in their old home again. Celebrating the twins’ birthday is a bittersweet experience, but the family gives Penelope her very own garden, complete with a butterfly wind catcher and a spot for her to plant her bee balm flower. Penelope loves her gift, and everyone wishes Bee a happy birthday, too. Marie looks at Penelope as her own person now, without the shadow of Bee hanging off of her. Bee will always be a part of her sister, but Marie’s perception of this has changed. Marie knows that her children all hope to move back to the woods and admits to herself that she wouldn’t mind it either. She wonders if Davina ever sought out her own daughter and reflects that Davina is healing slowly but surely. Marie decides that she wants to start painting. She looks to the future with hope.

Chapter 64 Summary: “Davina”

Davina stands in her garden, waiting for her daughter and two granddaughters to arrive. After sending an initial email, Davina received one back almost immediately. Her daughter, now named Nasrin, was told that Davina had died. She was thrilled to find out that she had a chance to meet her. They have arranged a visit, and Davina is anxious but excited. When Nasrin arrives with her daughters, Davina can tell that she is assessing her scars, as Nasrin is a trauma surgeon. While one granddaughter seems not to care about Davina’s injuries, the other is slightly on edge. The younger granddaughter wastes no time in asking to see Davina’s beehive, which makes Davina laugh. Everything feels natural, as though they never lost each other, and Davina takes her younger granddaughter’s hand, leading her over to the beehive.

Chapters 51-64 Analysis

At the story’s resolution, both personal and interpersonal conflicts are resolved. Davina forgives Brendon for burning down the cabin and helps him see that he can perform positive deeds to make up for his mistakes. The novel frames this as an act of encouragement as well as forgiveness, as Davina adopts the maternal role: She points out that he has already saved his dog, and her pinkie, and helped drive the boat when she needed help. Neither Davina nor Marie reveals Brendon’s secret, for once acting in a mutual effort to protect someone they both care about. Brendon feels proud of himself for his effort to change and counts his good deeds as he does them: “I liked seeing the progress I was making and knowing it was number four: I saved Banjo. I found the pinkie. I got us to the docks…I finished painting the house” (236). Marie tries to make a deal with Davina, but Davina acts offended by this, feeling that there is no need for any such thing. Where Butterflies Wander is a story of deeply flawed characters and how they navigate Death and the Grieving Process as well as their relationships with one another. Each has their own way of realizing these flaws and making genuine attempts to be better versions of themselves.

Marie experiences personal growth only in the story’s final moments and after weeks of pushing her own narrative. She sees that everyone around her is playing a role, acting in a way that pleases her. She comes to understand The Problem of Superficiality and how her pursuit of material gains to cover up her grief did nothing but create divides in her life. Marie attempts to redeem herself, much like Brendon, by salvaging some of Davina’s belongings and by finding Davina’s daughter. Davina long felt that there was no chance she would ever see her daughter again, so when the possibility becomes a reality, it is like all the negative experiences of the past several weeks are finally giving way to happiness and love. Davina feels overwhelmed with love when she meets her daughter and granddaughters: “I wonder if too much happiness can do that, literally blow up your heart. It feels possible, and if it is, I can’t think of a better way to go” (284). Similarly, when the community comes together to welcome her to her new home, Davina realizes that she has never really been alone.

While the novel shows that the grieving process never truly ends, it does end on a hopeful note as the family begins to heal in a healthier way. Brendon takes responsibility to resolve his guilt, and Penelope and Hannah support Davina as she recovers and starts a new chapter of her life. The family’s decision to move back to their original home is major because Marie’s constant longing to get away from the reminder of Bee is now replaced by a desire to be close to those memories. Penelope plants the bee balm flower in the garden at their home, symbolizing an everlasting connection to Bee and gratitude for the time the family got to spend with her.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 59 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools