Super Short Summary

In Too Good to Be True by Kristan Higgins, Grace Emerson, an English teacher, copes with her ex-fiancé dating her sister by pretending to have a new, ideal boyfriend named Wyatt. As pressure mounts to introduce him to her family, she befriends her attractive new neighbor, Callahan, an ex-con, complicating her ruse. The story reveals themes of love, family dynamics, and personal growth. Issues related to incarceration and deception are present.