44 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Inès continues her affair with Antoine, despite Edith’s disapproval. One day, she arrives at his apartment to find him visiting with two Nazi officers. When Inès questions him, Antoine confesses that he believes German rule will be good for France’s future. He defends the Nazis’ actions against Jews, and though Inès is uncomfortable with his ideas, she puts her doubts aside. Over time, however, she becomes less convinced. One night, she and Antoine see Jewish children being taken from the building across the street from them. Antoine defends the act, saying they’re being reunited with their families. Inès decides to return home to warn Céline of the increasing deportations, and Antoine reveals he knows about Inès’s friendship with Céline. Once Antoine falls asleep, Inès returns home. With Inès’s warning, Céline spends the next several days hiding away in Maison Chauveau's secret cave.
Sometime later, after the threat passes, Inès apologizes to Céline for her suspicions about Céline and Michel. Later, Inès apologizes to Michel for her absences and vows to become a better wife.
Céline considers her newfound respect for Inès and her secret affair with Michel. The next time they see each other in private, Michel confesses that he had sex with Inès. Céline is hurt but recognizes the hypocrisy of the betrayal. Michel brings Céline into his resistance activities, and she assists him with collecting and storing contraband weapons. A woman named Madame Gaudin arrives to collect them and privately warns Céline against pursuing her affair with Michel. After she leaves, Céline admits to Michel that she is pregnant. Michel is overjoyed, despite the complexity of their circumstance. They vow to continue their work to create a better future for their child.
Liv considers her feelings for Julien and her guilt at kissing him. She visits the Thierrys’ brasserie and inquires about its history. The restaurant manager tells her that the brasserie was once a watering hole for German soldiers, and that the Thierrys were instrumental in delivering information for the resistance. However, their subversive actions were not immediately known, and many thought they were collaborators. He also mentions that Edith Thierry’s best friend, Inès Chauveau, was killed for being part of the resistance. Liv returns to her hotel and finds her grandmother drinking Chauveau wine, but Grandma Edith avoids Liv’s questions about it. Instead, she tells Liv that Julien’s wife has been dead for six years. Liv realizes she misunderstood and leaves Julien a voicemail apology. Finally, Grandma Edith announces that they’ll be going on a guided tour of Maison Chauveau.
Inès tries to repair her marriage and hopes Antoine will just forget about her. However, Edith comes to visit one day, saying that Antoine is asking about her. Inès agrees to a meeting. On their way out, Edith congratulates Céline on her pregnancy. Edith and Inès discuss Inès’s hesitancy around Céline, and her feelings of displacement at Maison Chauveau.
At the brasserie, Inès tells Antoine she can’t see him anymore. He reacts by threatening her with his German connections before storming away. Ashamed, Inès drinks alone until Edith reappears and tells her they have other visitors staying with them. Edith introduces Inès to two Jewish refugees, the siblings Samuel and Rachel Cohn. Inès offers to house them in the Chauveau wine cellars, but Edith is cautious about trusting her.
While Inès is away, Céline and Michel discuss their new baby. Theo believes the baby is his. Michel tells Céline that he’ll be away the whole night on a secret mission, causing problems for German authorities. After Michel leaves, Inès arrives and questions Céline about his absence; she claims he’s visiting with another winemaker. Inès leads Céline to Edith’s car and reveals the two refugees. Céline takes them to a secret cave below the house and helps them settle in. Edith leaves, and Céline reconsiders what she knows of Inès.
Liv and Grandma Edith visit Maison Chauveau, where Grandma Edith becomes disoriented and emotional. While there, Liv receives a call from Julien and apologizes for her misunderstanding; they arrange for him to come join them at the winery.
When Michel returns home, Inès tells him about the refugees. Samuel Cohn promises to repay their kindness once he has received his degree to become a lawyer. He tells Inès about the true state of the German work camps, dissolving the lies she had been told by Antoine. He relates a story in which a French policeman died by suicide rather than arrest a young Jewish girl; his death gave the girl time to get away.
For several days, Inès, Michel, and Céline keep the Cohn siblings hidden from Theo until Michel can secure their passage out. After they leave, Michel tells Inès about a secret network in which he has contacts. Inès wants to help more people, but Michel believes it’s too dangerous to risk Theo becoming involved.
While Inès and Theo are both away, Michel and Céline discuss the possibility of becoming involved with the refugee escape line. When Céline brings up the idea with Theo, Theo adamantly opposes it and says the best way to survive is to stay out of the way.
Soon after, Céline is helping in the wine caves with Inès. Inès expresses concern over Céline’s advanced pregnancy, but Céline deflects and says the baby should know about wine. She realizes she was unconsciously thinking that her child would inherit Maison Chauveau. As they go outside, they meet Captain Richter and Herr Klaebisch, the wine inspector. Klaebisch goes to the caves while Richter stays outside with Céline. He tries to make Inès leave, but she refuses. Richter offers his protection to Céline and her baby in exchange for his friendship. That evening, he returns and forces Céline into the cellars where he attempts to assault her. However, Inès arrives, having seen them out her window, and hits him with a wine bottle.
Liv, Grandma Edith, and Julien begin their tour of Maison Chauveau. The tour guide recounts the house’s history, and when he mentions Michel, Grandma Edith becomes visibly upset. The tour group goes into the wine caves, and the guide tells them about the winemaking process. They reach the hidden cave where the Cohns were hidden, and Grandma Edith interjects to say that Michel was killed after an intimate betrayal. She leaves and goes deeper into the caves; Liv wants to follow, but Julien encourages her to leave Grandma Edith to herself. They go outside, and Liv becomes frustrated at Julien’s reticence to share Grandma Edith’s story. They begin kissing, and Grandma Edith arrives to collect Liv.
Inès and Céline wait with Richter’s unconscious body for Michel and Theo to arrive home. They descend into the caves, and Inès explains the situation; Michel knows that Richter can’t be allowed to survive. Inès cares for Céline while Michel and Theo kill Richter and dispose of his body. Afterward, Michel and Inès clean away any evidence of their crime. For several days, the household waits in fear of discovery; however, it appears Richter didn’t tell anyone he was going to Maison Chauveau, so no one comes looking for him.
One night, Inès wakes to find Michel missing. She goes downstairs and discovers him with Céline, revealing their affair. Now Inès realizes that Céline’s child is Michel’s. Heartbroken, she goes to see Edith. However, Edith is preoccupied with listening to an important conversation; she sends Inès away until she is finished. Feeling rejected, Inès goes to see Antoine. She lets herself in and drinks all the alcohol she finds. When Antoine arrives home, he finds Inès desperate and drunk.
In the morning, Antoine reveals that Inès confessed their crime against Richter and rapes her.
As the plot escalates into the second half of the novel, the three central women each process and manage their emotions regarding extramarital love, highlighting the theme of Loyalty and Betrayal. Céline and Liv are on opposite ends, with Céline believing in her connection with Michel and Liv vehemently distancing herself from what she sees as an unethical choice. Meanwhile, Inès’s affair puts strain on her friendship with Edith—arguably her only truly healthy relationship at this point in her life. During the early days of Inès’s affair with Antoine, she appreciates not just their physical connection but the way he shows an interest in her opinions and shares his thoughts with her. This suggests that despite Antoine’s nature, he does care for her in some way. However, when she ends their affair, he rejects her and then assaults her. These actions are born out of his wounded pride and need to reclaim his personal power. They also align with his Nazi sympathies as one who believes in subduing those he considers inferior through violence.
At this point, Inès’s journey turns inward, as her justifications for her actions fall apart in the face of the true horrors of the German occupation. When she feels Céline’s safety is at risk, Inès recalibrates her understanding of Antoine’s way of life:
The fear she’d felt for Céline had been real and deep, and the more she thought about it, the more she wondered how Antoine could possibly be right. He had so easily justified the Jewish deportations months earlier, and in the moment, his words had made sense. But what if Inès was the fool Michel seemed to believe her to be after all? (201).
At this point, Inès begins not only repairing her marriage with Michel but also building a new friendship with Céline. However, by this point too much damage has already been done. These chapters deepen the connection between Michel and Céline, with both believing they are living a story of true love, which merits Redemption and Forgiveness. Céline’s pregnancy effectively raises the novel’s stakes, forcing Michel to choose between his current family and his future. While Inès struggles to make amends for her mistakes, Michel draws further away. Finally, Inès faces the ultimate punishment for her betrayal: She finds her last avenue of validation closed to her, as Antoine reveals his true, sadistic nature. She puts her friends and family at risk, and she is sexually assaulted in a dark reflection of her romantic affair.
As the novel moves to the hiding of Samuel and Rachel Cohn, it strategically places the three central women together for the first time. Previously, Edith and Céline did not interact and remained in different physical spaces as well as different areas of Inès’s life. Although there is tension between the three women, this scene puts them on equal ground as they reach a mutual understanding and work toward a common goal. This is in contrast to the scene immediately following, in which Inès, as Grandma Edith, brings Liv to Maison Chauveau. Here, she is isolated in her own memories and wonders, “why I am the one still alive after all this time” (262).
The final chapters of this section introduce some of the most climactic moments, including Richter’s attack on Céline and his subsequent murder, the discovery of Michel and Céline’s affair, and Inès’s flight to Antoine culminating in her confession and assault. Although the attack on Céline is not born out of her own actions, the trauma and tragedy that Inès faces results from the choices she, Michel, and Céline have all made. The intensity and irreversibility of the actions that take place in these chapters close the novel’s second act, dividing each character’s life into a distinct before and after period before the third act begins.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Kristin Harmel