51 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Beck allegorizes Dante’s experience of entering hell and applies it to the presence of pain and suffering in a person’s life. She makes a distinction between the two terms, defining “pain” as the immediate emotional and physical effect of an event, while “suffering” is a feature of the way we choose to handle the events that happen to us. Suffering, then, can come as a result of our own thoughts, even thoughts which we convince ourselves that we believe: “Our worst psychological suffering comes from thoughts that we genuinely believe, while simultaneously knowing they aren’t true” (91, emphasis in original).
Such thoughts include beliefs like “money will make me happy” or “sticking to my unpleasant job is the path to success.” It is important to verbalize the actual truth in such circumstances, even if it might sound negative at first—for example, instead of the foregoing statements, being willing to say, “I’m getting more money but still feel unhappy,” or “I don’t like my job” will lead one closer to the truth.
Beck leads her readers through an exercise to consider the troubling “hellgate” topic they identified in Chapter 4, but now to observe all the frightening thoughts and fears one might have about that topic. Dante moves through the inferno not by hiding or turning away his gaze, but by observing the demonic tortures around him and asking questions about them. By observing our own thoughts and then asking the question of whether those fearful reactions are absolutely true, a potential way of freedom opens up. By acknowledging our thoughts and fears about this painful topic in our lives, and then asking ourselves if we are sure that those perceptions are accurate, we may have the opportunity to move on by acknowledging the pain, but then letting go of it rather than seeing it develop into persistent suffering.
Dante’s journey into the inferno takes him into the outer circles of hell, which contain those whose lives were marked by sins of incontinence—that is, an inability to control their behavior, leading to lust, gluttony, and other such things. Since these are sins rooted in the human tendency to seek pleasure, Beck refers to them as “innocent errors.” People fall into innocent errors by pursuing actions or lifestyles that they think should make them happy, only to find that they remain discontent in the end.
This can lead to an unrecognized division in our system of beliefs, in which we think we know how we ought to be living and try to push back the unwanted behaviors or emotions that come from our subconscious rebellion against those values. Beck makes an analogy with Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde from Robert Louis Stevenson’s famous novel, showing that many people believe that their attempts to be good (the Dr. Jekyll impulse) can effectively repress their unwanted emotions (Mr. Hyde) only to find that they cannot, because those habits represent an honest pushback from our deeper selves.
To identify the innocent errors that might underlie our inward conflict, Beck advises us to “walk back the cat,” a psychological method used to help analyze what has gone wrong in a situation. To walk back the cat, we should identify a recent episode of self-sabotage or unwanted behavior, and then think about what we were doing in the immediately-preceding moments. In this way, we can sometimes pinpoint the moment in which we chose a course of action against which our inner Mr. Hyde rebelled.
The belief on which that course of action was based—often an unexamined assumption of how we should act—should be subjected to inquiry. Beck tells her readers to consider that belief and ask, “Are you sure?” or even “Can you absolutely know that thought is true?” (120). When a false assumption has been identified, it can then be replaced with a truth more faithful to the guidance of one’s inner teacher.
In this section, Beck begins offering practical actions one can undertake to make progress toward full integrity. The preparatory phase from Stage 1 is complete; now, with Stage 2, we are beginning the journey.
Chapters 5 and 6 both deal with applying a practical method of handling our thoughts, a method that Beck will return to throughout the book. The method is based partly on Byron Katie’s work, and it includes subjecting our thoughts to careful inquiry. Just as Dante observes and asks questions on his journey, Beck advises a method of observing, asking questions, and moving on.
In Chapter 5, the object of observation is the fearful, painful reactions that we have in considering our “hellgate” issue. In Chapter 6, it is the potentially false thoughts we entertain about beliefs that we think will lead us to happiness. In both cases, Beck’s practical advice is to observe the thoughts, ask whether they are actually true, and then move on.
This methodology is an active one, focused on continual progress. As we observe and move on, we avoid getting stuck in any one place, and thus Beck’s method ties in with the theme of Finding Meaningful Change Through Small Steps. This practical pattern of inner observation, self-questioning, and moving on constitutes the steps that make up the progression of our journey. We may not attain full healing just yet from our “hellgate” issues, but by pressing forward, we can at least make space in our lives so that we are no longer held captive to that single issue. Now that we are following Dante’s onward journey through his descent into hell, Beck wants us to also feel the sense that we are making progress by working past issues in our lives, even if they might be difficult or alarming.
Once again, the theme of Integrity as the Key to Emotional Healing is the overarching idea that drives the whole narrative. In this section, it is present mainly as the end goal toward which we are pressing, while in later sections the practice of intentional integrity will also appear as one of the means toward that goal. Like in the previous section, however, it is the theme of Learning to Read Our Internal Signals that predominates. Stage 2 is concerned with one’s inner life, whereas later stages will focus more on outward action and external circumstances, so these Stage 2 chapters tend to highlight the importance of understanding our own inner state more than other sections of the book do.
Chapter 5 focuses on considering the inner signals relating to our “hellgate” issues—observing the emotional reactions and thoughts that arise from confronting those areas. The point here is not to dismiss them or even necessarily to understand them completely, but rather to observe them, acknowledge their presence, and introduce just a note of doubt over whether those thoughts really ought to have a permanent place in our lives.
Chapter 6, meanwhile, focuses on reading the signals that arise from a recent incident of unwanted behavior. By observing the thoughts and emotions that surround our frustrations with our own behavior, we may be able to pinpoint the reaction of our inner self to some prior incitement, and so gain a bit more insight into the values and desires that are of central importance to our inner guide. Chapters 5 and 6, then, while focusing on slightly different areas—“hellgate” issues on the one hand, and unwanted behaviors on the other—both maintain a steady focus on the theme of Learning to Read our Internal Signals.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
Mental Illness
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Oprah's Book Club Picks
View Collection
Philosophy, Logic, & Ethics
View Collection
Psychology
View Collection
Religion & Spirituality
View Collection
Self-Help Books
View Collection
Trust & Doubt
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection