57 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Background
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
When Lyssa was seven, she watched The Little Mermaid and was disappointed that Ariel would give up her whole life for a man. Now 30, she notes how the only interaction she has ever had with the sea is at her current job; she works in the gift shop of a museum that features a replica of the Titanic.
The museum makes most of its money from birthday parties and weddings held on the upper decks. Near the end of the summer, a pop star rents the entire Titanic for a music video. When the director sees Lyssa, she is chosen to dress up as a sea monster and work in the gift shop in the background of the video shoot.
Typically, her coworker, Mackenzie, is the one who dresses up and participates in parties and events, usually as a princess. Because she is Black, Lyssa usually doesn’t dress up; her boss claims that he wants to maintain “historical accuracy.” Now, Mackenzie is jealous and unsuccessfully attempts to get the director’s attention. Mackenzie tells Lyssa that she was probably chosen for the shoot because the director wants to sleep with her. This turns out to be true, as the director asks Lyssa back to his hotel after the last day of shooting.
Lyssa and the director have sex three times, and the third time, he does not use a condom. He tells Lyssa that he’s safe, and Lyssa says it is fine because she does not have any ovaries; after her mother died of ovarian cancer, Lyssa’s ovaries were taken out as a precaution.
Later, Lyssa reflects on how this is not true. Her mother did die of ovarian cancer, and afterward, the doctor told her that she should have her own ovaries removed as a preventative measure if she did not plan on having children. He told her to “Take care of [her] real future, not [her] imaginary one” (9). However, she has always found an excuse to avoid the appointments for the procedure.
During her mother’s initial appointments, Lyssa did her best to dress up and be as attentive as she could at the doctor’s office. Because she is Black and not wealthy, she feared the doctors judging her family or treating them like they weren’t real people. However, after a few months, she realized that there was truly nothing to be done for her mother, who died after 11 months.
While her mother was sick, Lyssa dated a man named Travis. As her mother’s sickness worsened, she did not have the energy for Travis and intended to break up with him. However, because of his supportiveness and effort in helping with her mother, Lyssa stayed with him.
One day when Lyssa’s mother needed medication, Travis went to the pharmacy to pick it up instead of Lyssa. However, when he showed Lyssa’s mother’s ID to the pharmacist, the pharmacist insisted that the ID was not enough. Travis argued, and security was called. Just before the police arrived, the manager—who knew Lyssa and Travis—arrived and gave Travis the medication.
Shortly thereafter, Lyssa told Travis about her oophorectomy. He told her to have the surgery if it’s what she needed to be healthy, but Lyssa was unsatisfied by his response; she hoped that he would have suggested having a baby first. Although her cousin tried to console her saying it was nice that Travis would rather have her safe than have a baby, Lyssa still broke up with him.
In the present, Lyssa and the director talk about the pop star. The director explains that the point of the music video is revenge against the pop star’s ex-boyfriend saying that she looked like a “monster.” In response, she made a sea monster music video. However, the director reveals that her ex-boyfriend never said that; the manager told the press that he did to motivate the pop star.
A few weeks after the video shoot, the music video is released. Lyssa sits in the gift shop and watches on her phone. Throughout the video, Lyssa is only shown for a handful of seconds at a time. In one scene, she is arranging the items in the gift shop, and she notes how the items in the shop cast shadows, leaving “the smallest spaces on her body all lit up with danger” (18).
Central to “Happily Ever After” is the allusion to The Little Mermaid at the start of the text. In that film, Ariel is a mermaid who falls in love with Prince Eric, a human. She is transformed into a human in exchange for her voice, and if she can get Prince Eric to kiss her before the end of three days, she can remain human forever. Although she fails, her father allows her to become human anyway. Lyssa notes that she cannot believe someone would leave her family and “the whole ocean for one man” (1). As such, the title of the story is ironic, immediately interrogating whether the typical ending to a fairy tale is actually happy.
Lyssa faces something similar to Ariel—a choice between safety or the classic happy ending of motherhood. Because of her ovarian cancer risk, it is recommended by her doctor that she have her ovaries removed; however, she struggles with this decision, not willing to give up her hypothetical family. She avoids doctor appointments and breaks up with her boyfriend because he wants her to have the surgery and preserve her health. From her point of view, this is a different kind of betrayal as he won’t commit to having a child with her. As she explains it, “[S]he half hoped he’d say, Well, if it has to be tomorrow, we have a baby tomorrow,” but instead, he tells her to have the surgery (14). Just like Ariel, who gave up her voice and then her family for true love, Lyssa is forced to determine what “happily ever after” means—a family of her own or a stronger guarantee of a long life. Like Ariel, Lyssa commits to a dream over safety, though Danielle Evans asserts that the situation is not so black and white. Life is ultimately more complicated than a fairy tale.
The comparison to The Little Mermaid is taken further when both the film and this story are viewed as passing narratives. In The Little Mermaid, Ariel passes for a human for three days, then commits her entire life to belonging to them, giving up her friends, family, and identity as a mermaid princess. This implies that humanity is inherently better than the race of mermaids, and the idea of Prince Eric going into the ocean is never considered. In “Happily Ever After,” Lyssa attempts to pass herself off as white—or as white as possible—to receive the best care possible for her mother. She is convinced that there is “medicine they didn’t bother trying on black women” (7) or that information will be withheld from her if she does not dress and act as professionally as possible. For the first part of her mother’s illness, she does her best to pass as white, but she realizes that her efforts are futile as her mother will die regardless. The complexities of Lyssa’s situation introduce the theme of Intersectional Discrimination: Skin Color and Gender. As a Black woman, she believes that she will not command the same respect that a man would or the same level of care that a white person would. This belief is rooted in real-life medical discrimination, and Black women are often disbelieved or mistreated by doctors. Since Lyssa’s mother’s cancer is fatal in any case, Evans asserts that passing is not the solution to medical racism; it can’t be up to Black patients to fix a broken system.
Travis adds another complex layer to the idea of intersectional discrimination. For months during her mother’s sickness, Lyssa goes and gets medication with only her mother’s identification. However, when Travis—who is “a man and a good three shades darker than” Lyssa (13)—tries to get the medication, he is stopped by the store clerk. For him, Lyssa’s mother’s ID is not enough, and when he tries to get help, security is called and he is nearly arrested. This interaction reveals the way Black men are viewed as dangerous or inherently criminal by racist societies, a different type of discrimination than the kind Lyssa endures as a Black woman. This idea introduces intersectional discrimination as multilayered, where gender plays a key role in determining how Black people will be perceived and treated. This idea is explored throughout the collection.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: