The Night Circus

1. General Impressions

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

• What were your favorite and least favorite aspects of The Night Circus? Discuss which relationships, plot points, and scenes were most emotionally impactful. 
• What other fantastical novels does The Night Circus remind you of? How does magic function similarly or differently from the ways it functions in similar texts?

2. Personal Reflection and Connection 

Encourage readers to connect the book’s themes and characters with their personal experiences.

• The novel explores manipulation and autonomy via Celia Bowen and Marco Alasdair’s storylines. How did you respond to their relationships with their mentors? Have you been involved in similarly complex power struggles, and how have these power dynamics impacted your relationships?
• Which aspects of Celia and Marco’s romantic relationship were most relatable to you? Were there aspects of their dynamic you found more or less believable? How does their romance compare to your own relationship experiences?
• The novel explores good and evil within the context of the Night Circus world. What aspects of this conflict are most analogous to moral dilemmas you have encountered in the relational, vocational, or familial sphere? 
• Isobel’s character ultimately controls the fate of the Night Circus. Which aspects of her situation were familiar to you? Would you have behaved the same way if you were in her position?
• Imagine that you were pitted against a magician the way Celia and Marco are pitted against each other. Would you behave in the same way as Morgenstern’s characters? Why or why not? What moral and ethical questions do you imagine this scenario would raise?

3. Societal and Cultural Context

Examine the book’s relevance to societal issues, historical events, or cultural themes.

• The Night Circus can act as an analogy for sociopolitical and sociocultural tensions between different ideologies. How does the novel use the old and new schools of magic to develop this commentary? What parallels do you see between the novel’s moral tensions and those in contemporary and/or historical societies?
• The novel explores the ways in which love might triumph over evil. How do these explorations relate to contemporary global conflicts? How has Morgenstern’s commentary on love expanded your outlook on international relations?

4. Literary Analysis

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and symbolism.

• The Night Circus toys with linear narrative structure. What function does this serve? How does the novel’s structure relate to Morgenstern’s explorations of time?
• Analyze and discuss the symbolic significance of the Wunschtraum Clock. What role does this repeated image play in Morgenstern’s explorations of history, time, and life cycles?
• How does the world of the Night Circus compare with the world beyond it? What is the significance of these disparities? Consider how the circus realm infuses the novel with mystery, wonder, and magic.
• Compare and contrast Celia Bowen’s and Marco Alasdair’s storylines and character arcs. What relationships, events, flashbacks, and descriptions does Morgenstern use to add dimension to their characters?
• Do you believe that Celia and Marco have free will? Are they able to make their own decisions; why or why not? How is their agency or lack of agency related to Morgenstern’s explorations of autonomy?

5. Creative Engagement

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book.

• Create a playlist that evokes the tonal and atmospheric shifts of the novel. Consider the historical time period and the novel’s fantastical elements. Describe and discuss your reasons for choosing each song.
• Imagine you were designing a cover for The Night Circus. What images would you feature, and how would you arrange them? What color scheme and fonts would you use? How would these elements communicate the book’s story, themes, atmosphere, etc.?

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources.