80 pages 2 hours read

Plutarch's Lives, Vol. 1

Nonfiction | Biography | Adult | Published in 100

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 12-14Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 12 Summary: “Pericles”

Plutarch begins his biography of Pericles with a reminder to his readers to seek to learn about what is worthy of study, namely, the deeds of virtuous men. He believes that his biographies can teach valuable lessons.

Plutarch describes Pericles’s background and early life. Pericles is born into one of the leading families of Athens, and his own greatness is presaged by a dream his mother has when she is pregnant with him, in which she sees herself giving birth to a lion. Plutarch describes Pericles’s appearance too, saying that he was handsome but that his head was elongated (for which reason artists always depicted him wearing a helmet). Pericles was well-educated, learning from some of the great philosophers and artists of the time. Pericles would remain particularly close with the philosopher Anaxagoras throughout his life. Plutarch highlights Pericles’s serious, composed, and rational nature.

Pericles initially avoids politics because he fears that he will be ostracized if he becomes too powerful, especially as he is already rich and well-connected. He enters the military and gains success. Eventually, Pericles does enter politics to advocate for the poor. He earns a reputation as an excellent speaker. Comic poets, however, often make fun of him for his lofty style, while some historians—especially Thucydides—have seen Pericles as a kind of de facto king of Athens. Plutarch highlights instead Pericles’s populist policies. Pericles’s main political rival is the conservative Cimon; when Cimon is ostracized, Pericles rises in power quickly.

Tensions with Sparta begin mounting, as the Spartans hate Pericles and Pericles is working hard to increase Athenian power in the Aegean and in Thrace. As Pericles strengthens the Athenian “Empire,” he also encourages the arts and sponsors building projects. During Pericles’s lifetime, the Athenians build many of their most famous monuments, including the Parthenon. As he becomes more powerful, Pericles increasingly rules Athens like a king and continues to operate in this way for 40 years.

Plutarch describes Pericles’s personal and professional qualities: his frugal nature, his philosophical interests, and his caution as a general. According to Plutarch, his greatest achievement was stopping the Athenians from overextending their empire and keeping the Spartans in their place. Plutarch also highlights the influence that Pericles’s mistress, the educated courtesan Aspasia, had upon Pericles. Some people say that one of Pericles’s most important conquests, the conquest of Samos, was done for Aspasia.

When Pericles denies trading rights to the neighboring city of Megara, he sets in motion a chain reaction that leads to war with Sparta—the Peloponnesian War. When the Spartans invade, many blame the war on Pericles and begin going after his allies, including the artists Phidias, Aspasia, and Anaxagoras. Pericles, however, is able to convince the Athenians to avoid meeting the Spartans in an open infantry battle, even when the Spartans begin raiding their territory: An open battle, as he explains, will favor the Spartans and will likely end in disaster for Athens.

As the Spartans raid the Athenian countryside, Pericles sends the strong Athenian navy to threaten the Peloponnese and has some success with this strategy. During his naval campaign, however, a plague strikes the Athenians, forcing Pericles to return home without a victory. He is stripped of his command and fined, though he is soon reinstated as the situation gets worse for Athens. Soon after, Pericles catches the plague and dies.

Chapter 13 Summary: “Fabius”

According to Plutarch, the founder of the family of the Fabii was a son of Hercules and a nymph, while Quintus Fabius Maximus is fourth in descent from him.

Fabius is consul five times. In his first consulship, he defeats the Ligurians and celebrates a Triumph in Rome. Later, when Gaius Flaminius is consul, the Carthaginian general Hannibal invades Italy, launching the Second Punic War. Hannibal easily defeats the Romans in early engagements. Declaring a state of emergency, the Roman senate makes Fabius dictator.

Fabius realizes that the Romans are no match for Hannibal in an ordinary battle, so he employs guerilla tactics to harass Hannibal’s forces. Though effective, these tactics are not popular with Fabius’s troops, who want to meet Hannibal in battle. While pursuing Hannibal, Fabius discovers that Hannibal has taken 240 Romans prisoner. When the senate refuses to pay their ransom, Fabius sells some of his own property so that he can pay the ransom himself.

Eventually, Fabius is forced to share his command with Marcus Minucius, his second-in-command, who is eager to face Hannibal in battle. Fabius and Minucius split the army; Minucius soon falls into a trap and loses much of his force to the Carthaginians. Fabius manages to save Minucius, however.

Fabius gives up the office of dictator, and the consuls who follow him initially continue his guerilla tactics. Eventually, the consul Terentius Varro resolves to meet Hannibal in battle. Varro fights Hannibal at Cannae and suffers a staggering defeat. The Romans, growing more desperate, put Fabius in charge again and reinstate his guerilla tactics. Fabius enjoys some success against Hannibal and reclaims some ground, including Tarentum. He celebrates a second Triumph in Rome. Soon, Fabius’s son becomes consul and leads the Roman army together with his father. Unfortunately, Fabius’s son dies young.

Later, when Fabius is older, Scipio Africanus attacks the Carthaginians in Africa. Fabius strongly opposes Scipio’s strategy. Scipio does eventually defeat Hannibal, but Fabius does not live to see it. He dies in poverty, so the citizens of Rome help sponsor his funeral.

Chapter 14 Summary: “The Comparison of Fabius with Pericles”

In a short comparison of Pericles and Fabius, Plutarch notes that Pericles led Athens when they were at their most powerful, while Fabius led the Romans when they were facing one of their most serious crises. Though Pericles had more regular military victories than Fabius, Fabius did manage to save the entire Roman army from Hannibal when Hannibal had trapped Minucius. In the end, however, Scipio’s defeat of Hannibal proved that Fabius’ strategy for dealing with Hannibal was not the only effective one (nor even the most effective one). Plutarch asserts that Pericles, ultimately, was a greater statesman and builder than Fabius.

Chapters 12-14 Analysis

Pericles and Fabius are both examples of The Role of Leadership and Morality in Public Life. Both men were politicians with impressive military records. In particular, it was the level-headed nature of both Pericles and Fabius that defined their success as generals: Pericles’s policy of refusing to meet the Spartans in an infantry engagement was essential to the strong Athenian strategy in the first years of the Peloponnesian War, while Fabius’s guerrilla tactics during the Second Punic War weakened Hannibal and stopped him from taking Rome.

Though both Pericles and Fabius were excellent generals with a strong army behind them, they both knew the limits of their strength and refused to be drawn into engagements that they couldn’t win. Plutarch thus uses his biographical approach to illustrate The Influence of Character on History, for it was the level-headed characters of these men that saved their respective states during a time of crisis. At the same time, Plutarch represents neither Pericles nor Fabius as perfect. Though both were capable leaders and military men, they were not always above reproach. Pericles was heavily influenced by his mistress Aspasia, which Plutarch suggests was a personal weakness, and even in his own time he was often ridiculed by his contemporaries for his lofty mannerisms (which earned him the nickname of “the Olympian”).

Fabius, on the other hand, was so convinced that his strategy for dealing with Hannibal was the best that he failed to see the strengths of the alternative strategy of Scipio, the general who would ultimately defeat Hannibal and Carthage. Pericles, moreover, becomes a somewhat ambivalent figure in terms of morality because of his association with controversial philosophers like Anaxagoras, who sought natural causes for things and who was often branded as an atheist. Pericles’s quasi-atheism is treated with suspicion by the devout Plutarch.

The weaknesses of Pericles and Fabius are an important aspect of Plutarch’s approach, however, for they serve as a reminder of how human nature ties different cultures and historical periods together. Plutarch’s exploration of his subjects’ weaknesses, here as elsewhere, humanizes them and sheds light on the individual human forces behind historical events.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 80 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools