One of Us is Lying

Consider each of the Bayview Four. Which characters would agree with the adage that “honesty is the best policy?” Which characters would agree with the adage that “a white lie never hurt anyone?” Would any of their opinions change throughout the novel? Why or why not?

Teaching Suggestion: This question links to the Personal Connection Prompt in the Pre-Reading Section and can work as either an in-class discussion or a personal writing prompt. Students can be flexible with their answers, as each of the Bayview Four may have reasons for agreeing with each of the different adages at different points in the novel. Students should be able to substantiate their point of view by citing specific passages from the novel.

Differentiation Suggestion: For classes or individuals who might benefit from a cooperative learning experience, students can work in groups to select one of the Bayview Four and focus on one character’s opinion of the adages (as opposed to all characters’ opinions). Alternatively, students can be split into four different groups, each of them focusing on one of the four characters in a jigsaw activity. Consider having students present their findings or lead a discussion based on what their group concluded.