32 pages • 1 hour read
On Being Sane in Insane Places
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Background
Sociohistorical Context: Psychiatry and Skepticism in the 1970s
“On Being Sane in Insane Places” is deeply rooted in the sociohistorical context of the 1970s, a period marked by significant skepticism toward institutional authority, including the fields of medicine and psychiatry. In the academic realm, particularly in the disciplines of psychology and psychiatry, there was significant expansion, with a renewed emphasis on mental health. However, this period also witnessed growing concerns about the influence and potential abuses of psychiatric institutions. David L. Rosenhan’s essay was a turning point in the psychological and psychiatric critique genre, which gained momentum in the wake of the anti-psychiatry movement. This movement, championed by figures like R. D. Laing, Thomas Szasz, and Michel Foucault, questioned the foundational principles of traditional psychiatry and its approach to mental illness. Rosenhan’s essay, providing empirical evidence, resonates with the movement’s critique of the often unreliable nature of psychiatric diagnoses and their extensive social and personal impacts.
The broader societal context of the 1970s further heightened the essay’s impact. The late 1960s and early 1970s were distinguished by antiwar protests, the Civil Rights Movement, and the emergence of various countercultural movements, collectively forging an environment conducive to reevaluating established societal norms. Rosenhan’s examination of the psychiatric establishment’s authority to label individuals as “insane” reflected an ethos that favored personal liberation over institutional power. Rosenhan’s findings found a receptive audience, and his essay emerged not only as a critical contribution to the discourse about the nature of mental illness and the role of psychiatric institutions but also as a work that reflected and shaped the broader values of an era.
Philosophical Context: The Medical Model of Mental Illness
“On Being Sane in Insane Places” explores and contributes to long-standing philosophical discussions about the medical model of mental illness. This model, prevalent in psychiatric practice, treats mental illnesses as primarily biological in origin, similar to physical illnesses. This view was also prevalent in the 1970s, though evidence for it was lacking. The predominant diagnostic manuals of the era, DSM-I and DSM-II, were steeped in psychoanalytic theories and lacked a robust empirical basis. The absence of uniform diagnostic standards often led to a variety of diagnoses for similar symptoms, undermining the trustworthiness of psychiatric assessments. These diagnoses usually mirrored prevailing sociocultural biases, tending to pathologize behaviors that diverged from societal norms rather than signifying actual mental health conditions. Nevertheless, much treatment presumed a physical basis for mental health conditions—hence the widespread use of psychotropic medication in Rosenhan’s study.
Rosenhan’s experiment challenged the medical model by showing how the behaviors of mentally healthy individuals could be misconstrued as symptoms of mental illness. His findings suggest that psychiatric diagnoses might be more influenced by the contexts in which observations are made rather than any objective criteria. Rosenhan’s critique aligns with broader philosophical discussions about the essence of “sanity”—a contested term with no clinical definition—and how mental illness is constructed. It challenges the notion that mental illness can be solely defined in medical terms and underscores the influence of social and environmental factors in psychiatric evaluations.
Rosenhan’s examination of the medical model extended beyond theoretical discourse, having tangible implications for psychiatric practice. His study, in conjunction with other pivotal works, contributed to heightened scrutiny of diagnostic methods and informed the development of more stringent diagnostic criteria in later editions of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) (Wilson, M. “DSM-III and The Transformation of American Psychiatry: A History.” The American Journal of Psychiatry vol. 150.3 (1993): 399-410).
Unlock all 32 pages of this Study GuidePlus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: