36 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
No One Is Talking About This opens with the unnamed female protagonist (hereafter referred to as “protagonist”) detailing her life in “the portal,” an online world that incorporates social media, blogs, media sources, and threads. The protagonist logs into the portal each morning and views funny videos and news. She observes the uncanny way the opinions of large groups of people depend upon a shared culture of approval, hatred, and judgment. The trends the protagonist engages with include class consciousness, absurdist politics, and developing news stories. The protagonist’s attention is mostly given to the portal. She notices her husband, brother, and mother only when they interrupt her focus on the portal.
The portal is described as omniscient and pervasive. It is suggested that the portal is a relatively new technological advancement: “The amount of eavesdropping that was going on was enormous, and the implications not yet known” (7). The protagonist has access to diaries, cameras, and conversations that are not explicitly consensual. While the protagonist participates in threads and posts her own material, suggesting that some platforms are consensual, her comment about “eavesdropping” implies that many people do not know they are being observed and uploaded to the portal.
The protagonist describes her country’s “dictator” as funny, irreverent, and absurd. Her theory of politics relies on the portal’s opinion—its memes—which she denotes as “absurdism” (4) without feeling inspired to contribute to a different politics. Though she mentions the presence of a man on the portal promoting socialism, the portal itself is so engaging that real-life politics does not occupy her mind for long.
The protagonist acquires fame in the portal with a single post: “Can a dog be twins?” (13). As her fame grows, the protagonist begins traveling the world to give interviews and presentations on topics related to the portal. As she gains awareness of the portal’s moral and social implications, the protagonist questions why she became involved with it in the first place and how she relates to it currently. The portal allows her to engage with the world in a predictable way. She is comforted by the knowledge that collective opinion in the portal is clear and she can be assured of always making the “right” decision, i.e., the most popular one. The predictability of the portal is its greatest attraction to the protagonist.
Police brutality becomes the most prevalent topic in the portal. The protagonist reacts strongly because her father is a retired policeman, and she has struggled with the cultural implications of her father’s career since she was a teenager. The protagonist recounts a few of the short poems she contributed to the portal, such as “that’s the cost of my vegan lunch” (20), which often feature a mash-up of seemingly unrelated words and references to popular culture. The dictator continues to rule as if his opinions are incontestable. After an election, her husband gets a tattoo with the words STOP IT along his hairline as a form of political protest. As the political climate of the protagonist’s country intensifies around issues of police brutality and white supremacy, the protagonist notes how easily people seem to disappear from the portal.
Her husband does not spend as much time in the portal as she does and will ask her if she is “locked in” before showing her pictures of roast chicken, which tend to bring her back to reality. When asked why he doesn’t contribute to the portal more, her husband responds: “Because I wouldn’t want to be full when I die” (21). The protagonist disagrees, believing in the importance of preserving information, images, and culture for the future.
As the protagonist travels to speak at events, she is questioned about whether her contributions are meaningful to society. She finds herself unable to explain the motivation behind her writing. She believes that, before the portal, an individual’s community and the “mental weather” they experience were not a matter of choice. In the portal, they are. As the protagonist spends increasing time in the portal, she begins to regard the people in it as more real than the ones she interacts with in reality.
Her husband then discovers that their neighbor is part of a reality television show. The couple watches the episodes with interest and the protagonist is disappointed to find that there is no mention of her existence at all. After she and her husband have sex, the protagonist reflects on her desire to be inconsistent above any other attribute.
The protagonist fantasizes about killing the baby that would grow to be Adolf Hitler to change her current reality. The protagonist acknowledges, however, that the emotions of the people that Hitler took advantage of in his rise to power would have still existed, and she questions what other uses those emotions may have been put toward. Furthermore, the protagonist considers that the capitalist, political, and technological society she lives in would not have happened if not for trains and the Industrial Revolution, which she resents.
The protagonist is banned from the portal for two days for taking an inappropriate and politically charged photo but quickly resumes her work traveling to different countries to speak about the portal. In Jamacia, the protagonist talks about the stream of consciousness, as she is becoming suspicious that her consciousness is influenced by the collective nature of the portal.
During her travels, the protagonist notes how cab drivers and acquaintances are likely to ask her about living in the United States, particularly about the issue of racism. The protagonist notices how pervasive American culture is by the number of Subway restaurants in international cities.
The protagonist considers the portal as the place where everyone can compile a complete identity and history for posterity and capture the culture in which they live. She considers her actions on the portal to be one “small stone on small stone on small stone” (47) in her pile of contributions to future generations.
The narrative style and format of No One Is Talking About This reflect the protagonist’s engagement with the portal. As her story is told in fragments separated by lines, and the average fragment is about one paragraph long, the format of the novel becomes a metaphor for the posts that the protagonist engages with in the portal. Each post is short and separated from the posts around it. While themes and trends connect the ideas of each post, their fragmentary nature suggests the quick turnover of news that the portal presents to the protagonist.
The portal is presented as a collective mind in that opinions about culture, morality, society, and politics are formed by the majority. The protagonist’s view of the world depends on the most popular topics in the portal. Furthermore, the protagonist finds assurance in the portal for its ability to tell her how she should think: “Her stupidity panicked her” (4). Her anxiety and fear at being left outside the collective are in tension with her “great shame about all of it, all of it” (6), She distrusts the authority she allows the portal to have in her life. Her fantasies about changing the course of the Industrial Revolution suggest that she does not want to be as consumed by technology as she is.
Beyond this, the protagonist questions who the collective is obedient to (9), and what party acts as its moral check. The users of the portal seem to operate solely on the force of the majority, without cultural, social, or political checks visibly swaying them in any direction. The protagonist questions the authority of the majority and whether the portal is truly democratic, or if instead it follows the whims of its most influential users.
Ethically, the protagonist does not know where she stands: “What did it mean that she was allowed to see this?” (8) When asked in an interview about the ethics and social impact of her posts, the protagonist does not know how to justify her position. She acts as the users of the portal expect without the time or will to question if these acts represent who she truly is.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features: