45 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The team gets ready to crawl down the air vents, with Malik staying on the roof to hold the rope that sends them down and will bring them up. Hector goes inside first because he’s the smallest. The three kids eventually reach the factory floor but find no equipment, confirming that the traffic cone business is merely a ruse.
They then discover a concealed lab area containing 18 screens that monitor locations all over town. Next, they find a room where the local newspaper Pax is prepared. It extracts only the good news from the nation’s regular newspapers and edits out any incidents of crime and violence. Moving down to the bottom level of the complex, the trio finds a conference room with walls that are lined with whiteboards that contain photos and reports detailing the development of each of them from the day they were born: “Eleven Serenity kids are chronicled in vast collages of pictures, papers, and notes” (171).
Eli uses his iPad to take photos of everything on the walls about the test subjects who are part of Project Osiris. When the kids hear the sound of a guard approaching, they duck into an air vent and make the excruciating climb back to the roof by pressing themselves against the sides of each air duct and inching upward. Malik is waiting tensely to hoist them back outside, but the three are too stunned to tell him what they found.
While her friends are engaged in their secret activities, Amber remains in the dark. She’s upset because Tori isn’t spending time with her, so Amber goes to Tori’s attic studio to work on their Serenity Day mural together. While she waits for Tori to get out of the shower, Amber stumbles across the photos that Eli snapped in the basement lab. When she confronts Tori about them, Tori admits, “They’re studying us the way a scientist studies the stuff in test tubes and on slides” (186). Amber refuses to believe this but agrees to keep Tori’s secret anyway.
Eli tries to make sense of the collage they found in the basement but has no luck until he finds a Wi-Fi hotspot close to the factory. There, he researches the two words “kids study” and “Hammerstrom.” To his horror, he discovers that his father is actually Hammerstrom, who has been studying the effect of environment on criminal behavior.
The experiment involves human cloning—the medical process of creating exact genetic twins of living people through the harvesting of their DNA. Under Osiris, clones would be created of the greatest criminal masterminds currently in prison. The babies born would be raised by surrogate parents in a fabricated community (199-200).
Hammerstrom’s research was initially supported by a billionaire named Tamara Dunleavy, but because of the controversial nature of his project, it lost university funding, and he resigned. After Dunleavy also broke ties with him, Hammerstrom dropped out of sight to conduct his own research secretly in Serenity.
Hector and the others are stunned when Eli shares his findings with them. They’re all clones of master criminals, and none of them have biological parents. They debate about informing the other children in the experiment, but Malik objects that they’d alert their caregivers. Even Amber can’t be told. The four teens resolve to escape from Serenity permanently, even though Tori doesn’t want to leave her family.
Knowing all these secrets and lies, Eli can barely get through his usual routine. He goes through the motions of being a dutiful son, a good student, and a star athlete while the group plans its next move. Mrs. Delaney notices that he’s off his game, but Eli is afraid to confide in her. Nevertheless, he thinks that she’s the only adult in town whom he’ll miss.
Tori is still undecided about whether to leave when she accidentally overhears a conversation between her parents about Malik. According to the experiment protocol, any subjects who exhibit bad behavior by age 14 will be weeded out. Tori races to tell this news to the boys and agrees to leave with them as soon as possible. Together, they plan to ride their bikes to the nearest train tracks that night and hop aboard a freight train bound for the city. That afternoon, Tori drops off the finished mural at Amber’s house and tries to say goodbye, but Amber still treats her distantly.
After Amber thinks about Tori’s behavior, she’s convinced that her friend is leaving and resolves to make a last-ditch effort to stop her. That night, she stays awake and waits until she sees Tori sneaking away on her bicycle. Amber follows on her own bike and catches up with the group at the edge of town. Just as she tries to persuade everyone to stay, they all get nauseous and dizzy. Eli explains that there must be some kind of barrier at the town’s perimeter to keep them from escaping.
The group hides in the bushes as they hear the Surety helicopter approaching. Not finding anything in its search beam, the aircraft moves away. Then, Mrs. Delaney arrives in her truck. She offers to take the kids back into town and pretend that nothing has happened. She explains that sometimes a breach alert is a false alarm, so the Surety will be unlikely to pursue the issue further. By the time they get home, everyone is feeling better, but Mrs. Delaney says, “I’ll keep your secret just this once, because it’s my secret too. But I’m not on your side. I’m not on anyone’s side, and I intend to keep it that way” (245-46). Amber, however, is finally convinced that something’s deeply wrong with the town of Serenity. She doesn’t even know herself anymore.
In this segment, four of the five main characters finally get answers about the mystery of Serenity, but this precipitates an identity crisis for them all. As they work through their issues and digest the new information they’ve received, the novel foregrounds the themes of Nature Versus Nurture and Clone Identities. Eli, Tori, and Hector find proof of their clone origins in the basement of the factory. This information explains much about why Serenity is so obsessed with maintaining a pleasant atmosphere:
Under Osiris, clones would be created of the greatest criminal masterminds currently in prison. The babies born would be raised by surrogate parents in a fabricated community, and carefully protected from any exposure to illegality, violence, deception, and fraud (199-200).
The town’s overemphasis on honesty finally becomes clear to the kids (or test subjects). Eli says, “When you think about it [...] all these things are tests of character. Are we honest or not? How do we react to disappointment?” (192).
More alarming than the experiment itself is the alienation that the teens now feel from their own families. They know that their cells were cultured in test tubes and implanted in surrogate mothers. They have no origin story of their own. Ironically, as the clones contemplate abandoning Serenity for good, they’re ambivalent about leaving their families. Tori is the most upset because she’s the only test subject who has a semblance of a normal emotional tie to her parents: “Infant Tori placed into the arms of the two researchers; it’s love at first sight! It could have happened that way. It probably happened that way. But is that enough?” (220). In the end, her surrogates are researchers and not biological parents. Eli takes a much more negative view of his own false family:
My father isn’t a mayor and a principal, he’s a scientist—a mad scientist. And he isn’t even my father. What he really is, I now realize, is the world’s greatest liar—his name, his wife, his town, his plastics factory, his newspaper, our so-called education, where one fact in ten might be true (211).
Malik is harsher still in assessing his surrogates. He tells Tori, “We don’t have parents [...] We have zookeepers” (209). Hector’s surrogates are the least parental of the lot, but even he has difficulty tearing himself away: “It hurts to hear it, even for me. My mom and dad should be the easiest of all to walk away from. But it doesn’t work that way. They’re not our real parents, but they’re the only ones we’ve ever known” (209).
Aside from the question of clone identities as they relate to the family group, the test subjects agonize over their real natures. Here, the nature-versus-nurture debate comes to the fore as each of the kids becomes alarmed at the prospect of acting out criminal behavior that’s genetically encoded in their cells. As Eli notes, “Everything I do—is it me deciding, or is it him?” (212).
This segment brings Amber into the group as well. Although she’s a test subject, she denies the validity of this assessment when Tori first breaks the news to her. As the supreme booster of Serenity, Amber doesn’t want to believe that she’s nothing more than a lab experiment. She becomes convinced of this truth only after getting sick at the town line, just like the others during their first escape attempt.
Back at home, as she reflects on the implications, Amber has the biggest identity crisis of the group: “Mostly, I feel stupid. I made endless lists, thinking I was in control of my life. And all the while, I didn’t have a clue what was going on in the world around me” (246). While Amber is concerned about the world around her, she’s even more deeply distressed by the world within her. Belatedly, she comes to the same conclusion as her fellow clones, pondering who she really is. The battle for identity intensifies when she wonders, “What is this place where I’ve spent my whole life? Who are these people who’ve always been here? Scariest of all: If I don’t know them, do I really know myself?” (247).
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Gordon Korman
Action & Adventure
View Collection
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Canadian Literature
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Nature Versus Nurture
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
Science & Nature
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection
YA Horror, Thrillers, & Suspense
View Collection
YA Mystery & Crime
View Collection