43 pages 1 hour read

Looking for JJ

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2004

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 1, Chapters 8-10Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 1: “Alice Tully”

Part 1, Chapter 8 Summary

Alice helps Frankie to pack up his belongings to move back home for summer break. Jill calls to let her know that they’ve come up with a plan to lure attention away from Alice by suggesting that Jennifer Jones has been relocated to Holland to live with an English family there. After the phone call, Frankie is suspicious and accuses her of seeing someone else, but they reconcile.

 

When the modeling work dried up for good, Jennifer had to go live with her grandmother for a while. Her grandmother has a small apartment and a mean-tempered dog named Nelson, and she isn’t happy to have Jennifer with her. After several weeks, Carol returns with a present for Jennifer, but leaves shortly after. Jennifer is disappointed when she discovers that the present is only a newer version of her beloved doll Macy. When Nelson won’t stop growling at her, she hits him with the doll and kills him.

 

Back in the present, Frankie drives off with his dad and Alice calls Rosie. Alice reflects that “the big things of life […] were ingrained […] lived in the fibres of the brain, in the tissue and the blood. They would always be there, curled up, sleeping in the unconscious, until something prodded at them” (84). There is no escaping her memories, no matter how hard she tries.

Part 1, Chapter 9 Summary

The news about Jennifer Jones’ move to Holland breaks a few days after Frankie leaves. The newspapers all run upsetting headlines, and Alice feels burdened and anxious with the news. While flipping through the newspapers at work, Alice glimpses her mother’s face in a different article. The article claims that Carol isn’t allowed to see her daughter. Alice tears out the picture and puts it in her pocket before returning the newspaper.

 

Alice reflects on her conversations with Pat when she was still at Monksgrove, the facility where she was kept after her trial. Pat details her unstable childhood and tries to make sure that she hasn’t been hurt or physically abused. Jennifer is confused and frustrated, thinking that, although there had been no abuse, “she’d just been sidelined, forgotten about. She’d been left with friends and family, the social services, complete strangers; finally when there was no one else she’d just been left on her own” (106)

 

Back in the coffee shop, Alice is counting inventory in the stock room. She takes out the photo again and reflects on how her mother had abandoned her as a child. Alice throws the picture in the trash. At the counter, she serves the detective, who says that he’s ending the investigation.

Part 1, Chapter 10 Summary

When Alice returns home, Rosie and her mother Kathy are having coffee. Alice is elated that the detective is leaving and that things will smooth over. They talk about vacationing in Majorca at Kathy’s house there, and Rosie offers to drive her mother home. Rosie and Kathy leave, and Alice heads to the bedroom, where she has partially packed a bag to go and visit Frankie. She reflects on “how lucky she was. […] And yet the past was there. It always would be” (113).

 

She thinks about what her future might look like and what it means to live a good life despite her past. She wonders:

 

[I]s this what she meant by a good life? […] Is this enough? To go to work every day? To have friends? To become educated? For what, in the end? To become a wife, a mother? Would it be better if she went abroad and worked among the hungry and the desperate? If she could prevent others from suffering and dying, would that make up for what she did six years before on Berwick Waters? Would it then be a life for a life? (113).

 

Rosie returns from the drive, bringing Sara with her. Sara reveals to Alice and Rosie that she is a reporter for a newspaper and has discovered Alice’s identity as Jennifer Jones. Sara is writing a book about the case and its aftermath and has been studying Alice for weeks. Sara reveals that the story is going to print in only a few weeks and suggests that Alice might want to have her own say in the story. Alice and Rosie are both devastated by the news.

Part 1, Chapters 8-10 Analysis

These chapters disclose more details about Alice’s unstable and unpredictable childhood. In her interactions with her grandmother’s dog Nelson, we get the first glimpses of Alice’s problems with anger and violence in the face of her many troubles. While Alice isn’t presented as a cold-blooded killer or someone who takes pleasure in cruelty, her emotions sometimes get the better of her, especially in painful situations, causing her to lash out. Alice’s troubled home life is only getting worse, with her mother unable to hold down a steady job and Alice spending more time with her terse and unwelcoming grandmother. Alice has clearly been negatively affected by her poor upbringing. The novel continues to develop the theme of the negative influence of child abuse and neglect, with Alice’s violent actions presented as a direct effect of her poor treatment at the hands of her mother and other relatives.

 

In the present day, Alice still deeply struggles with the events of six years ago. Although she tries to move on and make a fresh start, she also wants to prove to herself and others that she is a good person capable of a good life. Alice isn’t sure what a good life might entail and worries that nothing will be able to make up for what she has done. Despite this, however, Alice is momentarily hopeful, envisioning a happy future for herself with Rosie. The novel wrestles with questions of innocence and guilt, fresh starts, and lingering past events, without giving any firm answers.

 

At the end of this section, the life that Alice has made with Rosie is dramatically disrupted. The devastating news that her neighbor Sara is in fact an undercover reporter about to publish Alice’s identity and personal information shatters the stability and safety that Alice has come to rely on in her new home. These events seem to confirm Alice’s suspicion that she is unable to fully reconcile her identity as Alice with her identity as Jennifer. Instead, Alice is in danger of disappearing as soon as her identity as Jennifer Jones is revealed. The novel seems to suggest that, if anyone were to know her identity, they would hate her and think that she was evil, even as they love and support her in her identity as Alice Tully.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text