25 pages • 50 minutes read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: The source material and this guide reference the enslavement of Black Americans and the associated racism and prejudice.
In his speech, Lincoln frames the Civil War as not merely a human conflict but as Divine Retribution for the sin of slavery. He implies that both North and South are undergoing a shared ordeal that, though painful, is integral for the nation to emerge morally and spiritually rejuvenated. By saying the war was “give[n] to both North and South” (Paragraph 3), he hints that everyone involved is part of a larger, divine mission to right the wrongs of slavery. This shared suffering is viewed as a pivotal moment for change, with the war functioning as a necessary intervention to address the nation’s past errors. It aims to steer America toward a future marked by greater unity and a deeper understanding of justice. In this way, Lincoln’s address not only contextualizes the Civil War as a moment of divine judgment but also as a crucial step toward America’s moral redemption and the strengthening of its national character. Lincoln unites the two sides of the war with an undeniable connection to religion—God allowing the tragedy of the war insinuates its necessity in response to slavery.
This through line of divinity is further elaborated on throughout the speech, establishing that Lincoln believes there to be a clear exchange of evil behavior and evil retribution. By saying the war will continue “until all the wealth piled by the bondsman’s [...] toil shall be sunk” (Paragraph 3), Lincoln creates a direct correlation between the economic gains of slavery and the losses of the war. This implies that the war’s destruction is a way to balance out the unjust benefits gained at the expense of enslaved people, presenting the conflict as a tool used by God to dismantle the foundation of slavery.
Lincoln deepens this theme by referencing the idea that “the judgments of the Lord are true and righteous altogether” (Paragraph 3). This not only supports the notion of the war as a necessary evil in response to the evils of slavery, but also places it within a broader narrative of moral justice and goodness. Here, he suggests that the suffering and sacrifice experienced by the nation are aligned with a divine sense of fairness and purpose. This alignment casts the Civil War in a light of inevitability and righteousness, where the agony endured in war serves a higher moral correction. It is an appeal to the audience to see the conflict through a lens of faith and morality, understanding it as a pathway to fulfilling a divine mandate for justice. Lincoln, having established unity among both sides in response to tragedy, asserted the religious implications of this tragedy, and then reiterated the importance of goodness and faith, creates a perspective on the morality of slavery that is hard to ignore or oppose. This aspect of the speech aims to align more individuals with Lincoln’s goal of peaceful reconstruction.
Though some Confederate supporters claimed that they were fighting for mainly states’ rights, Lincoln puts slavery at the forefront with a clear and concise statement that cuts through the complexities of the war: “All knew that this interest [slavery] was, somehow, the cause of the war” (Paragraph 3). The word choice is deliberate. “Interest” refers not merely to a topic of concern but to a powerful force with vested economic and political stakes. Lincoln does not assign blame but suggests that the South’s dependence on enslaved labor fueled the flames of secession and that this was understood even at the war’s outset. At the same time, the word “somehow” introduces ambiguity, implying that what “all” Americans understood on an instinctual level was nevertheless difficult to articulate. This is in keeping with his later claim that neither the Union nor the Confederacy initially envisioned the war as a means of resolving the question of slavery. Rather, he says, “Each looked for an easier triumph and a result less fundamental and astounding” (Paragraph 3), implying that both sides sought to settle more peripheral concerns (like, presumably, the acceptability of secession). In this respect, Lincoln implies that the war has served a clarifying purpose, rendering its central cause—slavery—impossible to ignore.
This idea is implicit in the structure of Lincoln’s argument, which segues from its discussion of Americans’ initial understandings of the war to a statement about God’s providence: “The Almighty has His own purposes” (Paragraph 3). Lincoln then elaborates on the idea that the war is divine retribution for the sin of slavery, drawing pointed parallels between the violence of that institution and the violence of war—for example, the comparison of “blood drawn with the lash” to blood “drawn with the sword” (Paragraph 3). These parallels suggest that the war is a means of making slavery’s horror manifest to a country that had not fully reckoned with it. Likewise, Lincoln’s speech moves from framing the war in terms of a dispute over whether to remain united or divided to exposing the hypocrisy of such a framing. Pondering the unanswered prayers of both North and South, he remarks, “It may seem strange that any men should dare to ask a just God’s assistance in wringing their bread from the sweat of other men’s faces” (Paragraph 3). Lincoln here implies that whatever Confederate partisans believe themselves to be praying for, they are actually praying for the continuation of slavery, which the biblical reference positions as a fundamental violation of God’s law and an untenable foundation for a nation.
Lincoln’s address transcends pronouncements of victory. Recognizing the nation’s deep divisions, Lincoln prioritizes the need for National Unity and Reconciliation as the cornerstone of a lasting peace. Through his use of inclusive language, appeals to a shared future, and a focus on collective action, Lincoln crafts a message of healing and hope for a fractured nation.
One strategy Lincoln employs to foster unity is the use of inclusive language that transcends the victor/vanquished mentality. He avoids triumphalist rhetoric, stating that “[b]oth read the same Bible and pray to the same God, and each invokes His aid against the other” (Paragraph 3). The focus on shared beliefs and practices—the Bible and prayer—creates a sense of common ground despite the war’s bitter divisions. Lincoln reinforces this inclusivity with the pronoun “each,” acknowledging the humanity on both sides of the conflict. This strategy encourages a sense of shared responsibility for the war’s devastation and paves the way for a collective effort toward healing.
Lincoln states at the beginning of his speech that both sides “dreaded [war]—all sought to avert it” (Paragraph 2). This statement reflects a universal truth acknowledged by both sides of the Civil War: the shared desire to avoid the calamity that ultimately befell the nation. This acknowledgment serves not only as a reminder of the shared humanity between the opposing factions but also as a call to remember the pre-war unity that existed—a unity that Lincoln suggests can be rekindled and restored. The president’s call for reconciliation is not just about bridging the current divide, but also about returning to a shared understanding and mutual respect that predated the war’s outbreak. Lincoln’s observation that both sides did not expect the war’s “magnitude or the duration” (Paragraph 3) implies a shared misunderstanding that bridges sectional divides. By drawing attention to these shared misjudgments, Lincoln advocates for a collective approach to healing, hinting at the possibility of rebuilding a unified nation from the shared lessons of the war’s unforeseen challenges and outcomes.
Lincoln focuses on healing the wounds of a nation torn apart by civil war. The phrase “with malice toward none, with charity for all” (Paragraph 4) represents Lincoln’s vision of reconciliation, emphasizing the need for a compassionate approach to healing the nation’s divides. Lincoln uses the metaphor “to bind up the nation’s wounds” (Paragraph 4) to provide a vivid imagery of the healing process. This metaphor not only conveys the physical act of healing but also symbolizes the meticulous care and patience required to mend the rifts within American society. Lincoln extends this call to action with the phrase “to care for him who shall have borne the battle” (Paragraph 3), encompassing not just physical wounds but also the emotional and psychological scars borne by veterans. This suggests a long and arduous healing process, but one that is necessary for the nation’s survival. The focus on a shared future built on compassion and justice lays the groundwork for reconciliation. Through this imagery, Lincoln extends an invitation to all Americans to participate in the joint task of nation-building, giving the audience the shared responsibility in creating a climate of forgiveness and unity.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Abraham Lincoln
American Civil War
View Collection
American Literature
View Collection
Books on U.S. History
View Collection
Colonialism & Postcolonialism
View Collection
Essays & Speeches
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection
Mortality & Death
View Collection
Nation & Nationalism
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
War
View Collection