28 pages • 56 minutes read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Johnson, the main character in “Like A Winding Sheet,” is characterized by contradictions and ambiguities, especially regarding the type of man he thinks he is compared to his actual behavior throughout the story. Petry uses a limited omniscient narrator who speaks from a third-person perspective but is privy only to Johnson’s thoughts. This dynamic generates the irony of the story’s ending because closeness to his internal dialogue offers explanations—and evokes sympathy—for his behavior despite the violence that he ultimately uses.
Throughout the story, certain interactions between Johnson and Mae suggest that Johnson harbors increasing resentment for Mae as a result of his fatigue and work conditions. He notices, for instance, that she hardly ever seems as exhausted as he feels; he fixates on the fact that Mae’s factory has a more efficient payment system than his workplace; and he suggests that his fatigue may partially be Mae’s fault: “And he thought if he and Mae would go right to bed when they got home from work they’d catch a few hours of darkness for sleeping. But they never did” (Paragraph 48). Despite some subtle resentments, Johnson believes that he is the type of man who would never hit a woman, a characteristic that he continues to fixate on as he confronts women throughout the story. This internal repetition of his moral code shows his (initially controlled) desire to physically lash out in response to external stressors.
Johnson experiences racism at his workplace, which sparks his fury early in the story. He maintains, however, that he cannot hit a woman—even if she treats him with prejudice and contempt. At the factory, Johnson experiences symptoms of intense anger that will continue to reappear whenever his fury returns: tingling in his hands, a tense body and arms, and vivid imaginings of him striking women who anger him. Although Johnson continues to show restraint throughout the story, the tension in his body and the overpowering nature of his anger foreshadows that he is more inclined to violence than he knows.
At times, Johnson lets his anger overwhelm his understanding of reality. Johnson is deeply impacted by the structural and personal racism that he experiences at work, and he views most situations from this perspective—even if he is not entirely accurate in his assessment. For instance, Johnson storms out of the restaurant in a fury, assuming that the woman is racist; however, the narrative clarifies that the restaurant actually was out of coffee, and that the woman’s refusal to serve Johnson was not fueled by racism but coincidental circumstance. Due to Johnson’s blinding fury, however, he views this interaction as a personal, racism-fueled slight.
Johnson brings this fury home with him and, ultimately, proves that he is indeed the type of man he has tried not to be. He beats Mae violently, repeatedly punching her in the face, despite his continual insistence that he cannot beat a woman. As Johnson beats his wife, he thinks that he is helpless to this act—enmeshed in a winding sheet and unable to stop himself. Johnson’s sense of helplessness in the final scene complicates his character because he uses the winding sheet comparison to suggest that he is implicit in his own behavior. Although Johnson continues to beat his wife relentlessly, the narrative resists characterizing him as entirely amoral or not because of the narrative closeness to his psyche. He must endure a life of racism and economic exploitation, which humanizes him and offers an explanation for his anger, but Johnson nevertheless descends into the type of behavior that he spends the story trying to avoid.
Johnson’s wife, Mae, must also contend with harsh and exploitative economic conditions in New York City. She, like Johnson, works a night shift in a factory. She likely does not have as grueling of a job, physically, as does Johnson, as she seems well-rested and without pain in the morning. Mae has a warm and lighthearted sense of humor, which arises at both the beginning and the end of the story. She often lightens Johnson’s mood with teasing jokes, and her giggle is one of Johnson’s favorites of her characteristics. She is superstitious, as she wholeheartedly believes she shouldn’t leave the house on Friday the 13th. She also enjoys music, as she has the radio on when Johnson arrives home from work and frequently plays music through the night once they both arrive home.
Mae highlights how deeply Johnson is affected by his work and social conditions throughout the day. At the beginning of the story, their marriage is lighthearted and loving; the intensity of the day’s events and their impact on Johnson’s emotional state, however, change the dynamic of their relationship. When Mae tries to make a lighthearted comment to Johnson in order to dispel his bad mood, he descends into violence, viscerally and graphically hitting her in the face. This abrupt, horrific turn—from Mae’s sweet, cheerful disposition at the beginning to her violent beating at the end—augments the reader’s understanding of the depth of Johnson’s rage. Mae also represents a key figment within the Gendered Violence theme, illuminating how domestic violence is often a result of structural and social pressures that begin outside of the home. Further, Mae represents the ways in which broader prejudices of a racist society—including harsh economic exploitation and verbal abuse—can realize themselves within interpersonal and romantic relationships. In this sense, Mae is a tragic figure that experiences the burden of racism in a secondary way, as her husband releases his rage and resentment upon her through physical violence.
Mrs. Scott is the foreman at Johnson’s factory. She is a white woman who resents workers who arrive late and has very little sympathy for the grueling physical labor that the factory workers must contend with. Mrs. Scott represents the harsh economic reality for Black New Yorkers during this period, when factory workers were often at the mercy of white bosses who exploited them through long hours and little pay. Petry uses Mrs. Scott as a stand-in for white exploitative characters who benefited from Black culture and labor in 1940s Harlem.
Mrs. Scott is a racist character who holds prejudiced views against the Black factory workers. She believes that the Black workers tend to be late and that they use made-up excuses to explain their tardiness. She sees Black people as a dehumanized homogenous group, and this is represented through her use of racist and derogatory language toward Johnson individually and toward Black people as a whole. As a white woman with a leadership position in the factory economy, Mrs. Scott also believes that she is impervious to retaliations against her racism. This becomes clear when she is shocked and afraid of Johnson’s adverse reactions to her racist slurs. When she sees the fury that she has evoked in Johnson—and when she notices his balled-up fists and his intent to strike her—Mrs. Scott immediately retracts and backs away from Johnson. She is, however, unable to issue a genuine apology for her behavior, despite the fury she evokes. She attempts to protect herself by making feeble amends to Johnson: “Aw, forget it […] I didn’t mean nothing by it” (Paragraph 37). Her calm language and retreating demeanor represent constructions of white womanhood that maintains power by presenting itself as vulnerable and unthreatening while enacting violence.
Mrs. Scott represents the racist structure of economic life in New York City, but she also serves the story as the starting point of Johnson’s fury. She sparks Johnson’s rage through her racist language, and Johnson spends the rest of his day in an angry turmoil, seeing racism everywhere he goes.
When Johnson goes into a restaurant after work, he hopes to avoid the rush of the commute and to enjoy a cup of coffee. In the restaurant, a girl serves coffee at an urn, where a long line of workers waits for a cup. Although nameless, the girl serving coffee is an important figure within Johnson’s day, because she represents the way in which Johnson’s rage can be quickly carried over from one woman to the next. The girl’s appearance is not described at length, but Petry notes how the girl plays with her hair as she interacts with Johnson, lifting it off her neck and “tossing her head back a little” (Paragraph 55). Later, at home, Johnson will become frustrated with the similar way in which Mae plays with her hair. His frustration at these innocent behaviors suggests that Johnson is becoming increasingly angry at these women in a general sense, and that he is subconsciously grouping the women together to create a storm of fury surrounding all of their behaviors.
After dealing with Mrs. Scott’s racism in the factory, Johnson views the girl’s inability to serve him coffee as a racist slight. After she tells him that he will have to wait for a new batch, Johnson has another visceral image in which he violently beats her. The girl in the restaurant, then, becomes the new locale in which Johnson will pin his anger—even though she is only doing her job, and is not actively being rude or racist. Petry chooses to just call this character “the girl,” rather than personalize her in any way. This character’s namelessness suggests that she is an unassuming figure, a blank space that is simply a convenient placement for Johnson’s rage at that moment in time. This contributes to the idea of anger and violence in the story as an unpredictable emotion that can often appear in violent ways to undeserving women who are not themselves a cause for Johnson’s anger.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
By Ann Petry