In Praise of Shadows

Tanizaki argues that Asian cultures are more satisfied with their surroundings and find great beauty in them, while Western cultures are always looking to change their surroundings to create beauty from something new. Do you agree with this claim? Explain why or why not, and support your argument with examples.

Tanizaki writes from his own perspective and often includes personal anecdotes and opinions when crafting his arguments. While some may argue that this subjective viewpoint makes the work more effective, others may feel that the essay would be improved by an increased use of objective reasoning. In your opinion, does his use of point of view strengthen or weaken his claims? Explain why.

Tanizaki’s essay contrasts Western and Asian architectural forms, with examples like glass windows versus shoji and the high roofs of Gothic cathedrals versus the low roofs of Japanese temples. Extend this argument further by contrasting other architectural forms that were not analyzed in his essay. Alternatively, you may use examples that help complicate or reject Tanizaki’s claims.