Seen as the quintessential popular girl, Shara catalyzes the story's events by disappearing after leaving mysterious notes and sharing unexpected kisses.

A neighbor of Shara with a distinct edgy style, Rory is part of the stoners, skaters, and slackers group and plays a role in unraveling the mystery behind Shara's disappearance.

A football star at school who subverts the traditional jock stereotype, Smith is originally Shara’s boyfriend and navigates his relationship with her and others with sensitivity.

The head of Willowgrove Christian Academy and Shara's father, he embodies the authority and conservative stance of the school community.