How The Mind Works

Pinker distinguishes between the computational theory of mind and the metaphor of the mind as a computer. What are some of the key differences between the computation theory of mind and the computer metaphor of the mind? How do these key differences apply to the later arguments Pinker makes about complex concepts like emotions, relationships, and humor?

Pinker uses many examples to explain his ideas of how the mind works and to counter arguments against his ideas. How does his use of examples help or hurt his ability to make his argument? What would you recommend to Pinker to improve the clarity and strength of his argument?

Natural selection lies at the crux of Pinker’s argument about how the mind works. However, he must contend with considerable criticism and resistance to this idea despite his wealth of examples that natural selection is the only way to explain the human mind. Help Pinker with his argument by finding a couple of examples or explanations you did not find convincing and describe what is incomplete about the explanation and what evidence is needed.