58 pages 1 hour read

Half Brother

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Communication and Understanding

In Kenneth Oppel's Half Brother, the themes of Communication and Understanding are closely tied to the story, exploring the complex and tricky issues of human-animal relationships. Through the special bond between Ben and Zan, the novel shows how communication shapes relationships and how humans see intelligence and empathy. It raises important questions about how people treat animals and each other and what it means to understand another being.

For Zan, communication occurs almost entirely through American Sign Language (ASL), body language, and tantrums. While Zan can communicate his wants and needs with his caretakers, they do not always listen to him, even when they understand. Frequently, Zan expresses his desires only to have those around him ignore him. Further complicating others' understanding of Zan is his lack of effective communication with other chimpanzees. When Zan moves to Helson's ranch, he tries to communicate via sign language, but the other chimps do not understand him. Zan has no other way to communicate, as no one ever taught him how to communicate like a chimpanzee. This language barrier leads to difficulties integrating with other chimpanzees, as they do not understand him.

Ben is the only person who genuinely understands Zan. Ben is the first to criticize others for scaring Zan, reading and interpreting the chimpanzee's body language and signs. Zan returns Ben's understanding: "[Zan] sat down on top of me and patted me a lot. He knew how I felt. Sometimes brothers didn't need to say anything" (221). This concept that understanding does not require communication through language is a core component of the text’s argument that understanding is not dependent on language, and language can be a barrier to understanding.

While Zan illustrates understanding without language, Ben represents language without understanding. Ben is constantly at odds with those around him, unable to express himself in ways others understand. Sometimes, Ben's emotions impede his ability to communicate effectively, such as when he yells at his father or lashes out at Jennifer. Ben often has difficulties finding the right words to convince those around him. Even when Ben has the right words, he struggles to get others, particularly his father, to listen.

Richard struggles with empathy, which makes it difficult for him to understand others, even when they communicate clearly. Misunderstandings between Richard and Ben permeate the book. From the beginning, when Richard takes the family across the country for his new job without consulting either Ben or Sarah, to the end, when he chooses to end the research project without preparing Ben, Richard illustrates that understanding requires more than language. Richard represents the lack of Communication and Understanding, though his character arc proves him a better listener at the novel’s end.

Richard's continual insistence that Ben will "get over" his relationship with Zan is proof of how far-removed Richard is from ever understanding Ben. Likewise, there are no words Ben can use to convince his father because his father assumes Ben's behavior is just a phase. Richard lectures Ben on his sentimentality, not realizing that minimizing Ben's feelings is another barrier to understanding. In short, Ben and Richard communicate with common language, but no words can force them to understand each other.

Half Brother shows that understanding goes beyond just words. Through the relationships between Ben, Zan, and Richard, the novel highlights that communication involves empathy, respect, and genuinely listening to one another. Understanding someone else, whether human or animal, takes more than just speaking the same language.

The Challenges of Growing Up

The challenges of growing up are a central theme in Half Brother, explored through the experiences of the protagonist, Ben Tomlin, and the chimpanzee, Zan. Ben navigates the complexities of adolescence, family dynamics, and moral dilemmas, all while helping to raise Zan as part of a scientific experiment. Both Ben and Zan face significant challenges that test their character and shape their understanding of themselves and the world around them.

One of the main challenges Ben faces is adjusting to a new environment. At the novel's beginning, Ben's family moves from Toronto to Victoria, British Columbia, because of his father's new job. This move uproots Ben from his familiar surroundings and friends, forcing him to start in a new school where he struggles to fit in and establish his identity. The pressure to make new friends and gain acceptance is a common experience for many adolescents, and the novel captures Ben's anxiety and determination. Ben's desire to be accepted by his peers leads him to make choices that he later questions, like mimicking a chimpanzee in the cafeteria to establish himself as an alpha male, or his many interactions with Jennifer. Ben constantly struggles with frustration as he tries to find his place. However, Ben's anger and difficulties controlling his emotions make fitting in more challenging. Eventually, Ben gives up trying to be the "alpha male" and stops interacting with anyone socially. Later, with more growth and perspective, Ben starts interacting again, but this time without trying to fit a specific role. Likewise, Ben realizes his desire to control others is counterproductive and instead focuses on himself, offering a key difference from his father. Ben's struggle to find his place in a new environment highlights the difficulty of navigating social dynamics during adolescence.

The introduction of Zan into Ben's life adds another layer of complexity to his coming-of-age journey. Initially, Ben is skeptical and somewhat resentful of the experiment, feeling that it disrupts his already turbulent life. However, as he bonds with Zan, he sees the chimpanzee as more than just a research subject. This relationship challenges Ben to think deeply about empathy, ethics, and responsibility. Raising Zan requires patience, understanding, and a sense of duty—qualities that Ben must develop as he matures. Likewise, Ben's view of Zan evolves as the experiment goes on. Early on, Ben shares Richard's views that Zan is better off in the experiment than in the wild. However, as the experiment continues, Ben increasingly realizes the disservice the family has done to Zan. Ben shifts from demanding the Tomlins keep Zan forever to hoping Zan forgets about them. The responsibility of caring for Zan forces Ben to grow up quickly, balancing his own needs and desires with the well-being of the chimpanzee.

Ben's relationship with his parents, particularly his father, is another significant aspect of his journey toward adulthood. Richard Tomlin, Ben's father, is a stern and demanding figure. Richard's need for control creates tension between him and Ben, as Ben feels neglected and misunderstood. Richard's rigid expectations and lack of emotional support make it difficult for Ben to express his feelings and assert his independence. Throughout the novel, Ben grapples with the desire to earn his father's approval while also seeking to define his own values and beliefs. Eventually, both characters grow, with Richard relinquishing some control and Ben offering forgiveness. While Ben still respects Richard, Ben realizes that his father can be wrong. Ben's struggles with Richard are a crucial part of Ben's growth, as he learns to stand up for what he believes is right, even when it means going against his father's wishes.

Zan also struggles with growing up in the novel. Initially, Zan is compliant and easy to care for. Gradually, however, he begins to assert himself. Like Ben, Zan struggles to control his emotions, attacking people and throwing tantrums when he does not get his way. When placed in a new environment, specifically Helson's Ranch, Zan struggles with communicating with others. As he gets older, Zan becomes more insistent on his wants, forming his own opinions rather than just going along with those around him. However, while this is a critical part of growing up for any species, for Zan, this behavior makes him dangerous to the humans around him.

Zan's challenges in growing up parallel Ben's struggles. Both characters face identity crises, social integration issues, and ethical dilemmas. Zan's inability to fit in with either chimpanzees or humans mirrors Ben's struggle to find his place in a new school and within his family. Both must navigate the expectations placed on them by others while trying to understand their own identities.

Half Brother vividly illustrates the challenges of growing up through the experiences of both Ben and Zan. Through their relationship and evolving understanding of right and wrong, Ben and Zan ultimately emerge as more mature and self-aware individuals, embodying the difficult but essential process of growing up.

The Ethics of Animal Experimentation

Half Brother explores moral questions and ethical dilemmas regarding how scientific research treats animals, showing different views on animal experimentation through its characters as each takes a different view.

Ben's father, Richard Tomlin, is a severe and strict scientist who sees Zan mainly as a research subject. Richard focuses on the scientific breakthroughs that might come from the experiment, often ignoring Zan's well-being. For example, Richard installs a "learning chair" to strap Zan into when he is misbehaving, clearly ignoring Zan's needs and mental state. Richard's thinking highlights the ethical conflict between wanting scientific progress and caring for animals.

Ben initially sees Zan as a disruption to his life. However, as he bonds with Zan, he starts to see him as a sentient being with feelings and needs. This change makes Ben question the morality of treating Zan as a study object: "Zan wasn't human […] but not even a person? […] It didn't seem fair. I tried to think of what made someone a person, the unique things. And it seemed like Zan had all of them " (158). Ben's struggle reflects the considerable debate about what makes a person and what responsibilities humans have to animals.

Ben's mother, Sarah Tomlin, is in the middle of this ethical spectrum. She supports the experiment but also cares deeply for Zan. Sarah's character shows the struggle between scientific curiosity and compassion. She often mediates between Richard's strict scientific approach and Ben's emotional attachment to Zan. Although Sarah supports some of Richard's questionable choices, she quickly rescues Zan when he is in danger, even though she breaks the law doing so. Through Sarah, the text suggests that it is possible to balance scientific goals with the humane treatment of animals.

Peter McIvor also serves as an intermediary between science and empathy. He often argues with Richard about the methods used in the experiment. Peter opposes the use of devices like the "learning chair" and advocates for more ethical treatment of Zan. Peter changes schools to help protect Zan and even breaks the law. In comparison, Sarah has an internal code of ethics, while Peter willingly shares his. He makes a point to take Ben to a lecture on animal rights. However, unlike Richard, Peter does not try to bully others into following his beliefs. Instead, Peter asks questions and facilitates discussions to get his points across. His character highlights the importance of maintaining moral integrity in scientific research and that pursuing knowledge should not come at the expense of treating animals humanely.

Jack Helson, the head of the primate studies program at Seigal University, represents the darker side of animal experimentation. He uses harsh methods to control his primates, like cattle prods and pellet guns, and is willing to sell Zan and several other chimpanzees to a biomedical research lab. Helson's research and methods seem unnecessarily cruel, like isolating newborn gibbons for their first two weeks of life. Helson's character serves as a reminder of the potential for abuse in scientific research when ethical boundaries are ignored. His actions call into question what can happen when the humane treatment of animals takes a backseat to research outcomes and funding.

Half Brother provides a detailed look at the ethics of animal experimentation. The characters' different perspectives highlight the moral dilemmas and challenges of using animals for scientific research. The novel encourages readers to consider the ethical implications of their actions and balance scientific progress with the humane treatment of animals.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 58 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools