52 pages 1 hour read

Don't Let's Go to the Dogs Tonight

Nonfiction | Autobiography / Memoir | Adult | Published in 2001

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Themes

Negotiating Identity in a Postcolonial Context

Content Warning: This section of the guide describes and discusses the novel’s depictions of graphic violence, alcohol use disorder, death, sexual assault, and systemic racism.

Alexandra Fuller’s paradoxical relationship with her identity is a central theme in her memoir, shaping the portrayal of her childhood and her sense of self. Despite being born in England, Fuller’s formative years in Africa have profoundly shaped who she is. However, her upbringing in Africa is not without complications. Unable to define herself with a single, clear label, Fuller negotiates the disconnect she feels between her racial and national affiliations and her attachment to Africa.

Fuller nostalgically depicts Africa as her childhood home and evokes a deep sense of belonging to the land: “I fly home from university at least once a year […] I want to open my arms into the sweet familiarity of home” (287). Her descriptions of landscapes, wildlife, and cultural richness are filled with fondness and nostalgia. Thus, the very act of writing the memoir becomes a crucial part of her identity negotiation, serving as a platform for her to unpack the layers of her identity: “White,” “African,” “White-African” (10). Her return to childhood through writing isn’t merely a revisiting of the past, but a recognition of its influence on her present self. The paradoxical portrayal of her identity reflects the messy and unresolved nature of her ongoing negotiation for belonging in a postcolonial context.

Fuller’s memoir exposes the paradoxical nature of belonging for white settlers in Africa. For this, she employs a symbol comparing white settlers’ African identity to a snake shedding its skin. Through this image, Alexandra captures the artificiality of their claim in Africa, as well as the contradictions inherent in her attachment to the continent she too calls home: “[H]ow can we, who shed our ancestry the way a snake sheds skin in winter, hope to win against this history? We mazungus. We white Africans of shrugged-off English, Scottish, Dutch origin” (29). Alexandra highlights the fleeting nature of white settlers’ attempt to reinvent themselves in a new environment. Acknowledging the contradictions inherent in her attachment to Africa, Alexandra’s strategy is instead to distance herself from white supremacist ideology and refuse to embrace any single identity: “My soul has no home. I am neither African nor English nor am I of the sea” (36).

This self-professed rootlessness allows her to maintain a connection to the continent she cherishes while acknowledging the problematic history of colonialism and its enduring impact on her sense of belonging. While her body longs for Africa—its smells, its colors, its sounds—her soul rejects the racist ideology that prompted her very presence there. This internal conflict ultimately underscores the issue of identity in postcolonial times and the struggles one has when grappling with a multifaceted sense of belonging in a landscape forever altered by a colonial legacy.

The Impact of Colonialism and War

At the heart of Alexandra Fuller’s memoir lies an exploration of how colonialism and war have a lasting influence on individual lives. From the outset, Fuller emphasizes the harsh reality of her upbringing in war-torn Rhodesia, where violence and uncertainty were pervasive.

The narrative opens with a depiction of the Fullers living under constant threat, sleeping with guns by their sides. Such an immediate plunge into the harsh realities of their existence establishes the war’s pervasive influence and the fear and instability that characterized the era. Powerful symbolism aids in depicting a nation teetering on the brink of chaos. While traditionally a place of safety and refuge, their home in Rhodesia is depicted as a fortress, equipped with weaponry to ward off potential attacks. Described as isolated and unforgiving, Burma Valley’s perilous nature further reinforces a sense of hidden dangers. Decades later, this traumatic upbringing still manifests itself in Alexandra’s life, as she speaks of a lingering hypersensitive state and often wakes up startled, “the quick, gasping, suddenly alert way of all people who have lived in a war (and for which there is no cure, ever, not even now)“ (135). The echoes of violence continue to reverberate within her, highlighting the war’s enduring impact.

Innocence becomes another casualty of war, affecting both white settlers’ children and African children in profound ways. Daily life becomes a macabre dance with danger, where landmines and gunfire drills are normalized, weaving violence into the very fabric of childhood. Witnessing the horrifying aftermath of a bombed bus shatters any lingering sense of security, replacing it with a brutal awareness of war’s true cost. Conversely, African children bear both the brunt of the war’s brutality and colonial oppression. The Rhodesian government’s forced relocation of locals into guarded compounds exposes the war’s ability to dismantle innocence with ruthless efficiency: “Children of fighting age are kept at gunpoint” (106). Treated as potential threats, African children are displaced and robbed of their childhood, a policy reflecting the war’s deeply entrenched racism which later perpetuates cycles of violence and trauma. As innocence is stripped away, replaced by fear and uncertainty, the true cost of war leaves lasting scars on white and Black children alike.

Despite exposing and opposing her family’s overt racism and prejudices, Fuller falls short in critically engaging with the legacy of white settler colonialism. While acknowledging the poverty and corruption in the nations they settle in after leaving Rhodesia, the author overlooks how colonialism contributed to the broader systemic inequalities she witnesses. Her mother’s remarks about poverty, stating, “It was there before you noticed it [...] And it will be there after you leave” (239), reflect a reluctance to acknowledge involvement or responsibility. Such a mindset upholds a colonial narrative that characterizes Africa as inherently destitute and implies that European settlers’ involvement has been solely beneficial for the region.

Similarly, the author’s description of Malawi’s oppressive regime’s handling of foreigners and Malawians’ unjustified sense of racial superiority highlights a selective focus on immediate injustices toward white Europeans. Even in the context of a memoir—which inherently offers a limited, biased perspective—the narrative obscures liability, downplaying colonialism’s ramifications. Fuller hesitates to directly recognize the underlying legacy of colonialism and its lasting impacts on African societies and individuals, leaving her critiques ultimately lacking depth.

The Complexities of Personal History

Alexandra Fuller’s memoir chronicles a life profoundly shaped by a complex personal history, marked by both personal tragedies and the ever-present shadow of colonialism. From the early deaths of her sister Olivia and baby brother to the emotional neglect stemming from her mother’s alcohol use disorder, Alexandra confronts the traumas of her past with honesty and vulnerability, laying bare the emotional turmoil that stems from personal loss. However, the complexity of her personal history is further compounded by the historical context of her upbringing. Witnessing the violence of the Rhodesian Bush War forces Alexandra to confront not only the immediate aftermath of war but also the uncomfortable realities of her family’s presence as white settlers in Africa.

Behind personal and historical tragedies lies a thread of guilt, woven intricately into the fabric of the memoir. The sudden death of Alexandra’s younger sister, Olivia, casts a long shadow over her childhood. As she recounts Olivia’s passing, Alexandra wrestles with a sense of responsibility, questioning whether her actions or inaction played a role in the tragic outcome. This self-blame becomes a heavy burden, further complicated by a burgeoning awareness of the historical injustices woven into the fabric of her life. Her family’s position as beneficiaries of colonialism prompts further introspection, as she confronts the legacy of privilege and oppression intertwined with their presence on African soil. Ultimately, Fuller’s exploration of her childhood becomes a testament to the complexities of grappling with personal tragedies and the larger historical context of her time.

Personal tragedies are compounded by a sense of predestination that weighs heavily on Alexandra as she attempts to find closure. She shares a belief in forces beyond her control, a supernatural element woven into the fabric of her family’s experiences. The sheer number of tragedies that befall her family leads her to question whether their presence in Africa is somehow cursed: “Mum won’t kill spiders because she says it will bring bad luck. I tell her, ‘I’d say we have pretty rotten luck as it is’” (4). Alexandra’s exploration of superstition reveals an ongoing quest to come to terms with the losses that have shaped her. These beliefs offer a framework for processing her experiences, a way to find meaning in the face of tragedy.

This portrayal, while reflective of her emotional state, oversimplifies and homogenizes diverse belief systems present across Africa, reinforcing stereotypes of the continent as exotic and hostile. Thus, while Alexandra grapples with the complexities of her own life story and tragedies, her reliance on superstition as an explanatory framework underscores the intricacy of personal trauma.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 52 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools