57 pages • 1 hour read
496
Novel • Fiction
China • 20th century
2016
Adult
18+ years
Do Not Say We Have Nothing by Madeleine Thien spans generations, beginning with Big Mother Knife and her sister Swirl struggling to survive during the early years of China's Communist Revolution. Big Mother Knife's son Sparrow and Swirl's daughter Zhuli find solace in music amid the turmoil. As political tensions rise, Zhuli dies by suicide, while Sparrow's life is impacted by further events leading to his eventual death, pushing his daughter Ai-Ming into exile. Ai-Ming finds refuge with Marie, the daughter of a former friend of Sparrow, and relocates to America. The novel explores enduring themes of family, music, and resistance amid oppressive regimes. It includes traumatic events like political persecution, suicide, and the Tiananmen Square protests.
Melancholic
Contemplative
Bittersweet
Mysterious
Nostalgic
26,528 ratings
Loved it
Mixed feelings
Not a fan
Do Not Say We Have Nothing by Madeleine Thien intertwines Chinese history with personal narratives, earning praise for its rich storytelling and complex characters. Critics commend Thien's lyrical prose and intricate plot; however, some find the novel's pacing slow and its historical context challenging to grasp fully. Overall, a moving, albeit demanding, read.
A reader who enjoys Do Not Say We Have Nothing by Madeleine Thien likely appreciates multi-generational family sagas set against historical backdrops. Similar readers might also enjoy The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini or Wild Swans by Jung Chang for their rich narratives and deep cultural insights.
26,528 ratings
Loved it
Mixed feelings
Not a fan
496
Novel • Fiction
China • 20th century
2016
Adult
18+ years
Continue your reading experience
Subscribe now to unlock the rest of this Study Guide plus our full library, which features expert-written summaries and analyses of 8,000+ additional titles.