64 pages 2 hours read

Destiny Disrupted: A History of the World Through Islamic Eyes

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Introduction-Chapter 3Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Introduction Summary

Ansary grew up in Muslim Afghanistan, where exposure to a Eurocentric narrative of world history—such as through V. M. Hillyer’s Child’s History of the World—initially shaped his perspective. However, he later re-read Hillyer’s work and recognized its biases. Encounters with historian Arnold Toynbee and the influential book The Story of Mankind by Hendrick Willem Van Loon broadened Ansary’s understanding, embedding a Western-centric historical framework in his mind. Despite this, traditional Farsi history texts remained a staple in Ansary’s education, though he only studied them to pass exams.

Years later, while working as a textbook editor in the United States, Ansary faced the challenge of creating a world history textbook. This process involved interactions with various advisors, and Ansary discovered a tendency to minimize the significance of Islam in world history. His personal connection to Islam, through family heritage and scholarly exploration, contrasted with the prevailing view of Islam’s minor role in world history at the time.

Ansary’s reassessment of Islam’s historical impact, aided by maps showing the Islamic world’s considerable geographical span, revealed a significant yet often overlooked influence. The post-9/11 era rekindled Ansary’s interest in Islam’s role in global history, leading to deeper exploration and his realization that an alternative, parallel world history to the Western-centric narrative exists.

This book aims to present these discoveries in an engaging manner, drawing from scholarly works to illustrate the foundational narrative of Islam and its notable impact on world history. The book bridges the gap between historical account and myth, aiming to convey real struggles and achievements within Islamic history and offering a perspective that often remains absent in Western histories.

Chapter 1 Summary: “The Middle World”

The “Middle World,” defined by land routes, emerged as a distinct region before Islam, contrasting with the Mediterranean world that was shaped by sea routes. Ancient sea traffic centered around the Mediterranean, where numerous early cultures met, leading to the birth of Western civilization. In contrast, the Middle World, connected by overland trade routes, linked regions from the Indian subcontinent to Mesopotamia and Egypt, forming a nexus around the Persian Gulf, the Indus and Oxus Rivers, and various seas. This area, later known as the Islamic world, lacks a single label, but the author prefers calling it the Middle World for its position between the Mediterranean and Chinese worlds.

Geography isolated China and sub-Saharan Africa from these worlds, while the Americas formed a distinct universe due to their separation. Despite geographical barriers, the Mediterranean and Middle worlds were “intercommunicating zones” with distinct internal interactions and narratives of world history. These two worlds developed separate yet overlapping histories, particularly in the region encompassing modern-day Israel, Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan—a territory claimed by both the sea-lane-centered Mediterranean world and the land-route-dominated Middle World.

The Middle World’s narrative begins with early civilizations flourishing along fertile river valleys like Mesopotamia’s Tigris and Euphrates. This region, which would be in modern-day Iraq, witnessed the rise and fall of numerous empires, with a recurring pattern of city dwellers and nomads creating larger political entities through conquest and consolidation. This cycle, later codified by historian Ibn Khaldun, saw empires like the Sumerians, Akkadians, Babylonians, Assyrians, and Chaldeans rise to prominence, each leaving a mark on the region’s history and culture.

The Persian Empire, characterized by the difference in its governing style when compared with the more controlling Assyrians, marked a significant era in the Middle World. The Persians adopted a multicultural policy, respected local customs, and prioritized efficient communication and administration. Zoroastrianism, the dominant religion, introduced a dualistic worldview, influencing the region’s religious and cultural landscape.

Over time, the Mediterranean and Middle worlds witnessed shifts in power, with the rise of the Parthians and Sassanids in the Middle World and the transformation of the Roman Empire into the Byzantine Empire in the Mediterranean world. The Byzantine and Sassanid Empires dominated their respective regions, with their territories occasionally overlapping, especially in the disputed lands along the Mediterranean shore. This complex political landscape set the stage for the emergence of Islam in the Arabian Peninsula, poised between these two great empires.

Chapter 2 Summary: “The Hijra”

In the late sixth century, Arabian coastal cities thrived as centers of commerce, engaging in extensive trade with regions known for Christianity, Zoroastrianism, and Judaism. Arabs, mostly pagan polytheists, and Jewish tribes, who settled in Arabia following displacement by the Romans, shared cultural similarities and revered common ancestral ties to Abraham. In this milieu, Mohammed, born in the cosmopolitan town of Mecca, emerged as a figure of modest beginnings. Despite his early life challenges as an orphan, he gained a reputation for his diplomatic skills and moral integrity.

At 25, Mohammed entered into a successful and loving marriage with the wealthy widow Khadija; she was a reputed businesswoman in Mecca who was initially Mohammed’s employer. A profound spiritual experience in Mohammed’s later years led him to proclaim a monotheistic message, advocating for moral and social reform. His teachings challenged Mecca’s polytheistic and commercial foundations, sparking opposition from local business leaders and tribal power brokers. His uncle and guardian, Abu Talib, who was a powerful clan leader, supported Mohammed through these challenges. However, after the deaths of Abu Talib and Khadija, Mohammed faced increasing threats, culminating in a plot against his life.

The pivotal moment came when Mohammed and his followers migrated to Medina. This was called the Hijra, and it took place in 622 CE. It marked the inception of the Islamic community and the Islamic calendar. Medina, then torn by tribal conflicts, welcomed Mohammed’s reputation as a fair arbitrator. The Hijra symbolized not just a physical migration but the formation of a new social and religious order, with the Umma (Muslim community) at its core.

In Medina, Mohammed established a covenant promoting peace and mutual defense among its diverse inhabitants. Conflicts ensued with the Quraysh tribe and certain Jewish tribes, leading to battles and significant shifts in the power dynamics of the region. Despite initial setbacks, the Muslims’ determination and unity began to reshape the Arabian Peninsula’s sociopolitical landscape.

Subsequent years saw rapid expansion of Islam across Arabia, marked by Mohammed’s leadership in resolving conflicts and fostering a community bound by shared faith and values. His return to Mecca and the peaceful reclamation of the Ka’ba as a monotheistic worship site signified a major religious and cultural transformation. Mohammed’s final sermon emphasized principles of equality, justice, and the sanctity of life and property, reinforcing the fundamental tenets of Islam.

In 632 CE, after a pilgrimage to Mecca, Mohammed passed away in Medina, leaving behind a transformed Arabian Peninsula and a religious and social legacy that would impact the world. His death prompted a moment of crisis but also cemented his followers’ belief in an immortal and omnipresent God that transcended the life of any individual, even that of the Prophet Mohammed.

Chapter 3 Summary: “Birth of the Khalifate”

In the period following Mohammed’s death, the Muslim community grappled with the task of leadership transition, recognizing the need for a figure who could embody religious grace while also holding the community together. Abu Bakr, Mohammed’s close friend, assumed this role as the first khalifa, marking his tenure with a commitment to the principles established by Mohammed. Despite his unassuming nature, Abu Bakr successfully confronted challenges such as the Apostate Wars, thereby establishing the unity and indivisibility of the Muslim community.

Omar succeeded Abu Bakr and significantly expanded the Islamic empire through strategic military campaigns. Renowned for his stern yet just governance, Omar focused on codifying Islamic practices and laws, emphasizing the community’s egalitarian ethos. His leadership, characterized by an absence of pretension and a dedication to social justice, laid the groundwork for the comprehensive compilation of the Qur’an and the establishment of a legal and administrative system aligned with Islamic values.

This period that saw the rise of khalifas immediately after Mohammed’s death was named the time of the Rashidun—or “Rightly Guided”—Khalifas. It was a foundational era for Islam, witnessing the establishment of key religious, social, and political structures that would notably influence the future of the Islamic world. The leadership during this time not only expanded the territorial boundaries of the empire but also cemented the core principles and practices that would define Islamic civilization. The narratives of the Rashidun Khalifas, documented and passed down through generations, continue to shape the religious, cultural, and political discourse within the Muslim community.

Introduction-Chapter 3 Analysis

Ansary embarks on a journey to present an Islamic Perspective on World History, diverging from the traditional Western-centric viewpoint. His perspective is a product of a myriad of social, cultural, and intellectual influences. Growing up in Afghanistan provided Ansary with firsthand experience of Islamic culture, traditions, and historical narratives. This early immersion in the Muslim world’s historical context grounded his understanding of its complexity and significance.

However, even as a child in Afghanistan, Ansary’s early historical education comprised largely of Eurocentric narratives, such as A Child’s History of the World by British author V. M. Hillyer. This shows the extensive reach of Eurocentric views of history, though for Ansary, they were initially balanced by his exposure to traditional Farsi texts that offered counterpoints to Western-centric texts. Upon moving to the United States, Ansary entered a milieu saturated with Western educational paradigms and historical interpretations. This juxtaposition of Eastern and Western educational experiences played a pivotal role in shaping Ansary’s understanding of the need for a more balanced historical narrative.

Ansary’s introduction uses postcolonial and poststructuralist theory to reassess the dominance of Eurocentric historical narratives. Postcolonialism scrutinizes the cultural and power dynamics between colonizers and colonized, emphasizing the need to understand and validate the histories of formerly colonized regions and reveal voices and perspectives that have been suppressed or marginalized. Additionally, poststructuralism, which informs Ansary’s perspective, challenges the idea of a single, authoritative historical narrative, advocating for the recognition of multiple, often conflicting, perspectives. These academic disciplines challenge the notion of objective history by emphasizing the social constructions of knowledge and the power relations that inform historical writing. Ansary’s reevaluation of the Islamic world’s role in history echoes this approach, underscoring the importance of diverse narratives in constructing a more inclusive and multifaceted understanding of global history; this highlights the theme of The Impact of Historical Narratives on Cross-Cultural Understanding.

For instance, Ansary’s concept of the “Middle World” challenges the traditional Eurocentric narrative of history. Ansary points out that the term “Middle East” implies a Western perspective since the region would be on the east only relative to a western European. So, he chooses to call it the “Middle World” instead, and by delineating this region as a “world,” Ansary highlights its role as a distinct cultural and historical entity that served as a nexus between the East and the West. This term not only acknowledges the geographical significance of the area but also elevates its status as a cradle of civilization, commerce, and ideas. This portrayal sets the stage for understanding the emergence and spread of Islam not as a peripheral occurrence but as a central chapter in the shared human story, urging a reconsideration of conventional historical perspectives.

In later chapters, Ansary will focus on the concept of cultural hybridity, which emphasizes the intermingling and exchange between different cultures. This will echo Ansary’s exploration of the Middle World as a crossroads of civilizations, where the Islamic world not only emerged but also interacted with and influenced various cultures, leading to a tapestry of shared and divergent histories, ideas, and identities. Ansary’s own hybrid identity allows him to perceive the subtle ways in which cultures intersect, clash, and coalesce, making him particularly attuned to the nuances of intercultural exchange.

When discussing the birth of Islam, Ansary depicts the religion as being similar to many other world religions in the ideas it espouses. He shows that Mohammed endured opposition from the Meccans because his ideas of equity and social reform threatened the economy of the region and the power of the elites. Similarly, the first two khalifas, Abu Bakr and Omar, prioritized the principle of egalitarianism, just as Mohammed did, when they established a Muslim community with a formal legal and administrative system. By highlighting the idealistic beginnings of Islam, Ansary shows its ethical strengths. In a later chapter, he will go on to describe the Qur’an as a holy book that gives advice in very general terms, such as “Stop sinning; behave yourself; have a heart; you will be judged; hell is an awful place; heaven is wonderful,” and so on (93). This points to how Islam is like other religions in that it provides its followers with guidelines to live a good life. Given that popular depictions of Islam in the West vilify it for its violence and orthodoxy, Ansary offers these counterpoints. In these first chapters, he also depicts Khadija as a shrewd, wealthy businesswoman, which runs counter to popular narratives of Muslim women having no voice or power. Ansary indicates that while that might be the reality for some, there are diverse ways that women can exist within Islam since its adherents are a diverse group.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 64 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools