45 pages • 1 hour read
A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Karina’s best friend, Ashley, comes over and braids her hair. They take photos of themselves, eat snacks, and chat. Ashley asks Karina about Papa’s tutoring work and the friends discuss his and Chris’s new friendship: Karina tries to avoid Chris when he comes over although she’s been trying to let go of what happened last year. Ashley suggests that Chris might not be as bad as he first seemed. While she braids Karina’s hair, Karina stares at the valentine on the wall that Ashley made her years ago. She and Ashley have been best friends ever since Ashley gave her the construction paper tree covered with heart-shaped leaves.
Chris continues working with Mr. C. He loves Mr. C’s tutoring methods and is continuing to improve in math. Mr. C gives Chris treats and makes him laugh. One day, they take a break during their session to watch old basketball videos online. Chris is surprised when Karina joins them and chats about the videos, too. He’s even more surprised when she asks for his help with her photo competition before he leaves for the afternoon. She wants his opinion on which photo to choose for the gallery’s contest on the theme of home. Chris compliments all of the pictures but likes the one of the night sky best. Mr. C encourages Karina and Chris, promising to make them his late wife’s special cake when Karina wins the competition and Chris gets an A in math. Chris leaves the Chopra house feeling happy.
Karina keeps hanging out after school on Tuesdays and Thursdays during Papa’s tutoring sessions. One Thursday after tutoring, Karina, Chris, and Papa walk to the car together, eating fruit, chatting, and singing a song from Karina’s childhood. Out of nowhere, a car appears and the driver rolls down his window to ask Chris if he’s okay. Chris doesn’t know the man. The driver stops the car, gets out, and approaches menacingly. After studying the three companions, the man starts calling Papa racist names. He then pulls out a knife and demands that Chris and Karina give him their phones. He throws the phones into the bushes and threatens Papa. Papa tells Chris and Karina to run, but the man won’t let them. He continues insulting Papa, pushes him to the ground, and kicks him.
Chris is confused when the strange man approaches him, Karina, and Mr. C. But when Chris sees how the man is looking at Karina and Mr. C, Chris realizes what’s happening: a racist attack. The man calls Mr. C a terrorist, pushes him down, and kicks him repeatedly. Chris doesn’t know what to do.
Suddenly a neighbor emerges, sees what’s happening, and yells for her husband to call the cops. The attacker hears the woman and races away. Chris jumps into the bushes and grabs his and Karina’s phones so they can call their parents. The Chopras and Daniels arrive, followed shortly by the police and ambulance. Jay rides in the ambulance with Mr. C. Chris watches in amazement as Karina takes photos of “the spot where Mr. C fell” (56). She photographs Papa’s broken glasses, his missing shoe, and the smashed berries they were eating.
Chris and Karina go to the hospital afterward, too. The nurse treats Chris’s scratches and sends him home. He can’t sleep that night, terrified by what happened. He can’t stop seeing the attacker’s face and Mr. C’s twisted, injured leg. He calls Matt and tells him what happened. Then he bursts into tears. Matt encourages him to get some sleep so he can support the Chopras.
At the hospital with her family, Karina is so upset she’s shaking. Her parents comfort her. Then Papa’s doctor comes out to talk to the family. His eyes look like the attacker’s eyes, but Karina tells herself not to judge him because of how he looks. The doctor explains that Papa has to have tests and surgery. Dad stays at the hospital while Karina and Mom return home. That night, she lies in bed replaying what happened. In the morning, she realizes she overslept and Mom didn’t wake her; they will take the day off to visit Papa. At the hospital, Karina worries about Chris but is happy to see Papa. He is weak but makes jokes to make Karina feel better. He assures her that no one can defeat them. Karina feels better.
Karina sits in the waiting room with her family while Papa goes into surgery. She looks at the pictures she took of the incident and decides to post them online with a description of what happened. She wants the support of her family and friends.
Chris attends school the next day but regrets going when Karina isn’t there. He can’t focus. At lunch, he sees Karina’s pictures online. He remembers the stories Mr. C told him about his youth and coming to the US in the 1960s. Chris hopes Mr. C is okay and feels upset that anyone would want to hurt him. He comments on Karina’s post and hopes that other people support her, too.
During basketball practice, Chris gets angry when he overhears Quinn and his friends making fun of Karina and her photos. He confronts Quinn, but Quinn tattles on him for trying to start a fight. The coach benches Chris.
In the hospital waiting room, Karina continues to worry about Papa. She wonders what will happen if he doesn’t get better. Then her parents ask her about the details of the attack. Karina tries explaining and then shows them her pictures. Mom starts crying, blaming herself for telling Papa to tutor. Dad reassures her, insisting that it’s not her fault and that Papa loves tutoring. Shortly afterward, the surgeon tells the Chopras that Papa’s surgery was successful and that Papa is resting.
On Saturday, Chris’s mom takes Chris to the hospital to see Mr. C. Chris hasn’t liked hospitals since he had to get stitches as a child, but he wants to support the Chopras. They meet up with Karina and Trisha when they arrive, and all four visit Mr. C’s room. Shortly thereafter, two policemen arrive and ask Karina and Chris to identify the attacker from a lineup of photos. Karina, Chris, and Mr. C all identify the same man, so the officers leave to look for the suspect, who has committed other anti-immigrant acts in the past.
That night, Chris and his parents find an article in the newspaper about Mr. C’s attack. Chris doesn’t think that the article says enough about what really happened and how the man treated Mr. C. The Daniels family discusses hate crimes, which surprises Chris. However, he’s glad he can talk about these things with his parents.
The novel traces how Karina and Chris develop a friendship. At the start of the school year, Karina wants nothing to do with Chris. However, her feelings toward her classmate begin to change when her grandfather tutors Chris in math. Seeing Chris more frequently challenges Karina to embrace forgiveness. She tells her friend Ashley in Chapter 7 that what happened on the bus “feels like ancient history” (41)—she and Chris have both grown up since the bullying incident. Karina also demonstrates her maturity and her graciousness when she tells Ashley, “It’s good to give people second chances” (41). This scene reveals Karina’s capacity for empathy and love; she is willing to reconsider how she views Chris, demonstrating Tolerance and Acceptance of others’ flaws and mistakes. Once she decides to stop being angry with Chris, Karina changes their awkward dynamic to reconnect on new and different terms. For example, Karina now feels free to watch basketball videos with Chris and Papa, and even to ask Chris for help choosing her photo for the gallery competition. Both gestures demonstrate forgiveness, showing Chris that Karina is willing to put the past behind her. These scenes mark a turning point in the characters’ storylines, in their relationship as friends, and in the narrative as a whole.
Karina and Chris’s growing closeness will support and encourage them when they face complicated conflicts in their community and personal lives, emphasizing the Power of Friendship and Community. At first, when the new friends and Karina’s grandfather are attacked on the street, Karina and Chris feel confused, scared, and alone. However, once they remember the connection they’ve begun to establish, the new friends gradually rely on the strength of their kinship.
The violent assault on Karina, Chris, and Papa in Chapters 9 and 10 changes how they see themselves and others. The attacker’s verbal and physical aggression is representative of the prejudice and racism that many South Asian immigrants face in the post-9/11 American era. During the altercation, Karina and Chris feel powerless and helpless: They can’t defend Papa because they are children, because the man is threatening them, too, and because there is no obvious cause for the man’s violent behavior. The attacker disrupts their seemingly peaceful lives in Houston and forces them to pay attention to the bigotry that threatens their community. Because Karina and Chris are both close with Papa, they do not understand why anyone would insult and degrade him. Unlike the attacker, they see Papa’s humanity and know his innocence and goodness. They see him as a distinct person, whereas the attacker only sees him through his prejudice.
However, the novel makes a distinction between its protagonists’ reactions to the violence. In Chapter 10, the narrative reveals how the attack impacts Chris. When he calls his brother to discuss what happened, Chris cries and asks Matt questions about why something like this could have happened. While the novel is sympathetic to Chris’s feelings, Matt urges Chris not to focus only on his own reaction—instead, he should consider how much more impacted the Chopras must have been by the attack. This advice echoes calls for those not part of marginalized communities to be allies rather than “white saviors.” In Chapter 11, we see that Karina has been affected by the attack in far more dramatic ways: Her grandfather is facing surgery for his injuries, and she must navigate both specific fears for his health and more abstract fears about being targeted by racists.
These complex dynamics challenge Karina and Chris to face adversity with resilience and to call upon their friends and community for help. Karina’s social media posts are symbolic of her need to be supported by others during this crisis: She shares her pictures and posts with family and friends because she realizes that “Papa needs their prayers, and [she] need[s] their support” (67). Chris in turn realizes that he must be a friend to Karina when he sees the post online. Not only does he face his fears to visit Mr. C in the hospital, but he also tells off Quinn for mocking Karina’s pain despite getting into trouble with the coach. Together, Karina and Chris push back against the feeling of danger that the attacker has created—Houston has always felt safe, but the attacker has threatened this once-secure sphere. Karina builds a place of safety online by posting photos and soliciting the good wishes of those who know Papa; Chris does his best to make sure their school remains a welcoming and safe place as well. The novel therefore suggests that the best way to withstand injustice is to rely upon the support and love of one’s family, friends, and community.
Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.
Including features:
Art
View Collection
Books About Art
View Collection
Childhood & Youth
View Collection
Community
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Fear
View Collection
Friendship
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Pride & Shame
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection