Ashes Of Roses

What techniques does the author use to foreshadow the tragic event of the fire and the factors that contribute to it? Include at least three different examples to support your response.

Analyze Rose’s first explorations into the broader landscape of New York. What misconceptions of America does she have, and how do her first interactions disillusion her?

Analyze the most prominent incidents in which women and girls are treated differently than men. How does this attitude affect the fate of the Nolan family?

Throughout the novel, Rose relates a variety of recollections about her time in Ireland. How do these contemplative moments enhance the author’s depiction of Rose’s character and current situation?

Research the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory in greater detail. How does the author employ historical facts to create an accurate depiction of this event? What aspects of the fictionalized version are distorted or overemphasized?

Given the disparities in the treatment of men and women in America, how might this story have changed if Da had stayed and Ma had returned to Ireland with Joseph? Use evidence from the text to support your answer.

What is Mr. Garoff’s true opinion of the Nolan girls? Does he only barely tolerate them, or does he hide his true sentiments under a gruff exterior? Support your interpretation with evidence from the story.

Examine the author’s depiction of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire. Given that this was a real-life event that claimed many lives, does the author handle the descriptions of the fire with sensitivity, or does the text cross the line into lurid sensationalism? Use examples from the text to support your interpretation.